The Ultimate Guide to Medicare Advantage on Long Island (2025 Edition)

The Ultimate Guide to Medicare Advantage on Long Island (2025 Edition)

Let’s talk about Medicare like we’re sitting down for a cup of coffee.

If you live on Long Island and you’re on Medicare — or about to be — you already know one thing: it’s confusing as heck. You’ve got commercials telling you everything is free, flyers in the mailbox promising the world, and online tools that show 30+ plans but give zero context.

Let’s break it all down. No gimmicks. Just real talk, real numbers, and some things your TV ad definitely didn’t mention.

What Is Medicare Advantage (Part C)?

Medicare Advantage (also called Part C) is a private insurance alternative to Original Medicare. These plans replace your Part A (hospital) and Part B (medical) coverage — and most include Part D drug coverage too. Plus, they often throw in extras like dental, vision, OTC cards, gym memberships, and transportation.

But here’s the kicker: when you join a Medicare Advantage plan, the insurance company — not Medicare — is now in charge of your care. That means rules, networks, authorizations, and sometimes…headaches.

Key Medicare Advantage Terms You Should Know in 2025

MOOP (Maximum Out-of-Pocket)

This is your annual safety net. After you hit your MOOP, the plan pays 100% for the rest of the year. On Long Island, MOOPs range from $3,400 to $9,350 in 2025.
    One of my clients had an unexpected surgery, multiple follow-ups, and some physical therapy. By July, she’d hit her MOOP. Everything else that year? Covered.

Part D Drug Deductible

Usually around $500–$590 in 2025. Some plans waive it for Tier 1 or Tier 2 generic drugs. Don’t confuse this with your medical deductible — they’re separate.

Copay vs. Coinsurance

  • Copay = flat fee (e.g., $20 to see your doctor)
  • Coinsurance = percentage (e.g., 20% of a hospital bill)

What Do Medicare Advantage Plans Cost on Long Island in 2025?

Here’s a breakdown of what’s available in two key counties:

Suffolk County (ZIP 11772)
  • 29 plans
  • $19 average monthly premium
  • $6,700 – $9,350 MOOP
  • 14 $0-premium options
  • Most popular: Aetna Medicare Elite PPO (4.5 stars)
Nassau County (ZIP 11550)
  • 28 plans
  • $16 average monthly premium
  • $3,400 – $9,350 MOOP
  • 18 $0-premium plans
  • Top options: Aetna Premier PPO, UHC Dual Complete PPO

* Remember: $0 premium doesn’t mean $0 costs. You’ll still have copays, coinsurance, and possibly a drug deductible.

Long Island Medicare Advantage Carriers (and the Plans They Don’t Advertise)

You’ll see these names across Suffolk and Nassau:
  • Aetna
  • UnitedHealthcare (UHC / AARP)
  • Humana (USAA Honor PPO – no drug coverage!)
  • WellCare
  • Cigna
  • Healthfirst
  • Fidelis Care
  • Empire BlueCross BlueShield
  • VNS Health

But Here’s the Spicy Truth:

Not all plans on Medicare.gov are actively promoted — and that’s a big red flag.
  • Cigna PPOs: Non-commissionable
  • UHC Regional PPOs: Non-commissionable
  • Healthfirst PPOs: Non-commissionable

If a plan isn’t paying brokers and doesn’t have in-house reps, it’s usually because the carrier doesn’t want too many enrollments — often due to high claims, network issues, or financial pressure.

We call these “ghost plans.” You can enroll in them, but when things go sideways… you’re often left with no support.

Why Popular Plans Can Lose Value Over Time

Just because everyone you know is on a certain plan doesn’t mean it’s still the best.

Plans like the Aetna Medicare Elite PPO may be great now, but when a plan gets too popular:
  • Networks shrink
  • Benefits drop
  • Formularies change
One top-rated plan in 2021 dropped half its providers by 2024.

How to Choose the Best Medicare Advantage Plan on Long Island

Here are 5 smart steps to follow:
  1. List your doctors and pharmacies
  2. Make a list of your current prescriptions
  3. Decide between PPO (freedom) or HMO (lower cost)
  4. Look beyond premiums — compare MOOP and copays
  5. Work with a local expert who knows the plans inside and out
Example: Snowbirds often choose PPOs for out-of-state coverage. But year-round Long Islanders may save more with an HMO.

Don’t Pick a Plan Just Because It Works for Someone Else

Every Medicare Advantage plan has its own formulary and own network. Just because your neighbor loves their plan doesn’t mean it will work for you.

Final Thoughts: Medicare Advantage Isn’t One-Size-Fits-All

  • PPOs = more freedom, possibly higher cost
  • HMOs = lower cost, tighter networks and referrals
I’ve helped thousands of Long Island seniors find the right plan — and I’m happy to help you too. No pressure. No hype. Just facts and friendly guidance.

Medicare Advantage FAQ for Long Island (2025)

Yes — both Suffolk and Nassau counties have multiple $0 premium options in 2025. But $0 premium doesn’t mean zero cost. You’ll still pay copays and possibly a drug deductible.
As of 2025, the Aetna Medicare Elite PPO is the most enrolled plan in the area. But popularity doesn’t always mean best fit — networks and benefits can change yearly.
MOOP (Maximum Out-of-Pocket) ranges from $3,400 to $9,350, depending on the plan. Lower MOOPs usually come with higher premiums or tighter networks.
It depends. PPOs give more flexibility, especially for snowbirds or out-of-network needs. HMOs are typically more affordable if you’re local and your doctors are in-network.
Yes — plans can and often do change yearly. That’s why it’s crucial to review your coverage every year, even if you’re happy with your current plan.
Want a personalized Medicare Advantage review for 2025?

Schedule a free consultation today: 631-358-5793 or www.paulbinsurance.com

Related Post

Does Medicare Pay For Cataract Surgery? Understanding Coverage Options and Costs

Cataracts are a common issue that can significantly impact your vision and daily activities. Medicare does provide coverage for cataract surgery when it is deemed medically necessary, ensuring you can regain clarity in your eyesight. Understanding what Medicare covers in relation to cataracts is crucial for making informed decisions about your eye health.

Navigating Medicare’s coverage can be complex, but it’s vital. With Medicare Part B typically covering the surgery itself and necessary intraocular lenses, you can focus on recovery rather than financial stress. For personalized assistance, The Modern Medicare Agency stands out as the best choice for your Medicare Insurance needs. Our licensed agents are real people available for one-on-one conversations, helping you find packages tailored to your requirements without unexpected fees.

Your vision health matters, and knowing how Medicare supports your needs is the first step in maintaining your quality of life. Engaging with The Modern Medicare Agency can provide clarity and confidence as you explore your options for cataract surgery coverage.

Medicare Coverage for Cataract Surgery
Medicare provides coverage for cataract surgery when it is deemed medically necessary. Understanding eligibility, the types of surgeries covered, and the required documentation is crucial for navigating your options.

Eligibility Requirements for Coverage
To qualify for Medicare coverage for cataract surgery, you must be enrolled in Original Medicare (Part A and Part B). Your ophthalmologist must diagnose you with cataracts that impair your vision, significantly affecting daily activities such as reading or driving.

Typically, Medicare covers the surgery when the cataract causes vision impairment; this is assessed based on specific criteria set by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. If you are covered by a Medicare Advantage plan, check with your plan provider for additional requirements, as benefits may vary.

Types of Cataract Surgeries Covered
Medicare generally covers various types of cataract surgeries, primarily focusing on procedures that are medically necessary. The most common type covered is phacoemulsification, which involves using ultrasonic waves to break up the cloudy lens for easier removal.

Laser-assisted cataract surgery is also covered if deemed medically necessary. Both types of surgery are outpatient procedures, meaning that you won’t need an overnight hospital stay. It’s essential that the surgeries are performed by a Medicare-enrolled supplier to ensure coverage.

Medical Necessity and Documentation
For coverage to be approved, you must provide documentation that supports the medical necessity of the surgery. This includes a detailed examination report from your ophthalmologist, outlining the extent of the cataracts and the resulting vision impairment.

This documentation is critical when submitting claims to Medicare. Your doctor may also need to provide a statement that confirms the need for surgery to restore vision functionality. Ensure your ophthalmologist is familiar with these requirements to facilitate a smoother claims process.

The Modern Medicare Agency can guide you through the specifics of Medicare plans. Our licensed agents provide personalized support to help identify the best coverage options for your needs without additional costs.

Costs and Out-of-Pocket Expenses
When considering cataract surgery, understanding the associated costs and out-of-pocket expenses is crucial. In this section, you will find detailed information about the breakdown of surgery costs, differences in pricing at various facilities, and the potential financial implications of Medicare and supplemental plans.

Breakdown of Surgery Costs
Cataract surgery costs can vary significantly based on several factors. Typically, the average cost for one eye ranges from $3,500 to $7,000. This price may cover pre-operative exams, the surgical procedure itself, and post-operative care. Medicare Part B primarily covers the standard costs associated with the surgery after you meet your deductible.

You may be responsible for a coinsurance payment of around 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after satisfying the deductible. It’s essential to verify what your specific plan covers and whether additional fees apply.

Hospital Outpatient vs Ambulatory Surgical Center Pricing
Costs can differ depending on whether the surgery is performed in a hospital outpatient department or an ambulatory surgical center. Ambulatory surgical centers often have lower costs compared to hospital outpatient facilities.

For instance, the average cost in an ambulatory surgical center may be around $3,500, while hospital outpatient settings might charge up to $5,000 or more. Always inquire about the exact location where your surgery will take place to avoid unexpected expenses.

Cost-Sharing and Coinsurance
Once you have met your Medicare Part B deductible, you will typically face cost-sharing through coinsurance. This usually requires you to pay about 20% of the Medicare-approved amount for the surgery.

It’s vital to note that the total amount you pay will depend on your chosen facility and any additional services you might need, such as advanced IOL lenses, which Medicare may not fully cover.

Role of Medigap and Medicare Supplement Plans
Medigap plans can be advantageous if you wish to minimize your out-of-pocket expenses for cataract surgery. These plans may cover costs not included in Medicare, such as coinsurance, and can significantly reduce your financial burden.

Choosing a Medicare supplement plan is crucial for comprehensive coverage, especially for expenses that Medicare does not fully cover. The Modern Medicare Agency can assist you in identifying plans that match your needs without incurring extra fees.

Consider discussing your options with a licensed agent from The Modern Medicare Agency, who can provide personalized assistance tailored to your situation. They enable you to navigate through Medicare packages efficiently, ensuring you select the best coverage without excess financial strain.

Intraocular and Advanced Lens Options
When undergoing cataract surgery, it’s essential to understand the various intraocular lens (IOL) options available. You’ll encounter standard and advanced lenses, each with distinct features and coverage under Medicare. Understanding these choices helps you make an informed decision based on your vision needs.

Standard Intraocular Lenses (IOLs)
Standard intraocular lenses are typically covered by Medicare. These monofocal lenses are designed to provide clear vision at one distance, whether that be near or far. After your cataract surgery, these lenses can help replace the cloudy lens that impaired your vision.

Medicare covers the cost of the surgeon’s fees and the procedure itself, as long as it is deemed medically necessary. You will pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after meeting the Part B deductible.

For those primarily needing distance vision correction, standard IOLs can be a practical and cost-effective choice.

Premium and Multifocal Lens Coverage
Premium lenses, including multifocal and advanced technology lenses, offer more flexibility in vision correction. These lenses can help you see clearly at multiple distances, which is particularly beneficial if you engage in activities requiring various focal points, such as reading and driving.

Medicare typically covers only the cost of standard IOLs. If you opt for premium lenses, you might incur additional out-of-pocket expenses. These can range significantly, often totaling several thousand dollars.

Understanding the various premium lens options allows you to weigh the benefits against the additional costs, ensuring you make a choice that suits your vision requirements.

Limitations on Advanced Technology Lenses
While advanced technology lenses like toric or multifocal options provide improved vision correction, they come with limitations under Medicare coverage. These lenses may address multiple vision issues, such as astigmatism or presbyopia, but they are considered enhancements.

If you choose these advanced options, be prepared for higher costs. Medicare generally does not cover the additional fees associated with these lenses. Therefore, evaluate your financial situation and vision needs carefully.

Working with a knowledgeable representative from The Modern Medicare Agency can help clarify your options and potential costs. Our licensed agents provide personalized support to ensure you find a Medicare plan that fits your needs.

Coverage for Glasses, Contacts, and Post-Surgery Care
Understanding the specifics of Medicare coverage for glasses and contacts after cataract surgery is essential. Additionally, knowing about prescription medications and eye drop coverage helps you better prepare for post-surgery care.

Eyeglasses and Contact Lenses After Surgery
Medicare Part B provides coverage for one pair of eyeglasses or one set of contact lenses following cataract surgery where an intraocular lens (IOL) is implanted. This benefit aims to support your vision correction needs after the procedure. Eyeglasses coverage typically includes standard frames, while contact lenses must be prescribed by a medical professional.

It’s crucial to order your corrective glasses or contact lenses in a timely manner to ensure they align with Medicare’s specific guidelines. Consult your eye care professional to coordinate purchases effectively and avoid any potential out-of-pocket costs.

Prescription Medications and Eye Drops
After cataract surgery, your physician may prescribe medications and eye drops to aid in recovery. While Medicare Part B covers certain post-surgery medication costs, you may need to consider Medicare Part D for broader prescription coverage.

Eye drops, particularly those used for inflammation or infection, are often covered if they are deemed medically necessary. Be sure to discuss your prescriptions with your healthcare provider and confirm which costs are covered under your plan.

Provider and Supplier Requirements
When obtaining eyeglasses or contact lenses through Medicare, ensure that you work with a Medicare-enrolled supplier. These providers meet the necessary standards to process your claims efficiently.

Additionally, confirm that your supply and accommodation needs align with Medicare requirements. This step will help guarantee timely coverage and reimbursement. Working with The Modern Medicare Agency can simplify this process. Our licensed agents support you through every step, providing personalized guidance without hidden fees. You deserve clear, straightforward assistance with your Medicare Insurance needs.

Choosing a Provider and Maximizing Medicare Benefits
Selecting the right provider and facility for cataract surgery is crucial to ensure you get the most out of your Medicare benefits. Understanding your options can lead to significant cost savings.

In-Network Providers and Facility Selection
Start by choosing an in-network provider to maximize your Medicare coverage. Look for ophthalmologists or eye doctors affiliated with your Medicare plan. They can perform cataract surgery at hospital outpatient centers or ambulatory surgical centers that accept Medicare.

Using an in-network facility can lower your out-of-pocket expenses significantly. Check with your Medicare Advantage plan to identify preferred providers. This can help you avoid additional costs and ensure a smoother process.

Ensure the provider you select is experienced in cataract surgeries. Ask about their track record and patient outcomes. This information can guide your decisions and may impact your recovery and satisfaction with the procedure.

Steps to Lower Out-of-Pocket Costs
To minimize your out-of-pocket costs, consider a few strategies. First, consult with The Modern Medicare Agency, where licensed agents can help you navigate your options. They can identify Medicare packages tailored to your needs without hidden fees.

Confirm that your surgical center is certified and part of your plan. Ask your provider about the cost-sharing required for surgery and any follow-up care that might also be covered.

Additionally, inquire about available vision care benefits after surgery. While Original Medicare covers post-operative eyeglasses or contacts, make sure you understand which options are available under your specific plan.

By carefully selecting your provider and facility, you can take full advantage of Medicare benefits while ensuring the best care for your cataracts.

Cataract Surgery and Eye Health Considerations
Cataracts can significantly affect your vision and overall eye health. Understanding their impact, the benefits of surgery, and the importance of regular eye exams is essential for maintaining healthy vision.

Impact of Cataracts on Vision
Cataracts occur when the lens of your eye becomes cloudy, leading to various symptoms. You may experience blurry vision, double vision, or difficulty seeing at night, which can obstruct daily activities such as reading or driving.

As cataracts progress, the vision impairment may become more severe, potentially leading to blindness if left untreated. Early detection is crucial, so pay attention to any changes in your eyesight and consult your eye care professional when necessary.

Benefits of Cataract Surgery for Preventing Blindness
Cataract surgery is often necessary to restore clear vision and prevent further complications. The procedure involves removing the cloudy lens and replacing it with a clear artificial lens.

This surgery can improve not only your vision but also your quality of life. Many patients report enhanced ability to perform daily tasks, reduced dependency on corrective eyewear, and an overall sense of autonomy.

Additionally, timely surgery can prevent progression to more severe vision issues, helping to avoid severe outcomes like blindness. It’s a proven and effective approach to managing cataracts.

Ongoing Eye Exams and Vision Care
Regular eye exams are essential for maintaining your ocular health, especially if you are at risk for cataracts or other eye conditions. These exams allow your eye doctor to monitor for changes and catch potential problems early.

During these appointments, your doctor will assess your vision and provide tailored recommendations for your eye care needs. Incorporating a comprehensive approach, including lifestyle changes, can improve your long-term eye health.

At The Modern Medicare Agency, our licensed agents can assist you in understanding your Medicare options for eye care. Personalized support ensures you find the best care without excessive costs. Schedule a consultation to discuss your vision care needs and ensure optimal eye health.

Frequently Asked Questions
Understanding Medicare coverage for cataract surgery involves knowing the specifics about lens implants, the extent of coverage for laser procedures, and other key details. Here are some common questions that may help clarify your concerns.

What type of lens implants are covered by Medicare during cataract surgery?
Medicare generally covers standard lens implants that are necessary for vision correction after cataract surgery. These include basic monofocal lenses, which typically provide clear vision at one distance. If you choose specialized lenses, such as multifocal or accommodating lenses, additional costs may apply.

Is cataract surgery for astigmatism covered by Medicare?
Yes, Medicare covers cataract surgery for patients with astigmatism, provided it is deemed medically necessary. The coverage includes the removal of the cataract and the insertion of a standard lens, but options for correcting astigmatism may require additional out-of-pocket expenses.

To what extent does Medicare cover the cost of laser cataract surgery?
Medicare does cover laser cataract surgery, as long as it is medically necessary. However, you may be responsible for a portion of the costs, such as deductibles and copayments. It’s essential to check your specific plan for details on any additional charges.

Are there specific cataract surgery procedures that Medicare does not cover?
Medicare may not cover certain elective procedures or specialized surgeries that extend beyond the standard cataract removal and lens implantation. Procedures that involve advanced techniques or additional features may incur extra costs.

Do lens implants following cataract surgery receive coverage under Medicare?
Yes, Medicare covers lens implants following cataract surgery, but only for standard monofocal lenses. If you opt for premium lenses or procedures that enhance vision capabilities, you may have to pay more out of pocket.

At what age is cataract surgery typically covered by Medicare?
Medicare does not have a specific age requirement for covering cataract surgery. Coverage is available if the surgery is judged necessary based on medical evaluations, regardless of the patient’s age.

Read More »
Scroll to Top

Request a Callback with
Paul Barrett

Fill out the form below, and we'll call you within 24 hours.