Farmingdale Medicare Agent – Trusted Local Medicare Help

Compare Medicare Advantage & Medigap Plans from Leading Carriers — All in One Simple Review

Schedule Your Free Consultation

New to Medicare in Farmingdale? Already Enrolled? Turning 65? I’m Here to Help.

Whether you’re turning 65, still working past 65 and transitioning off employer coverage, already on Medicare and reviewing your options, or under 65 due to a disability — you deserve clear guidance, not confusion.
And with the Annual Enrollment Period ending December 7th, now is the time to make sure you’re in the right plan for 2026.

I proudly help every type of Medicare consumer in the Farmingdale area:

Turning 65

First-time Medicare enrollment, important deadlines, penalty avoidance, and choosing the right plan

Still working past 65

Coordinating Medicare with employer-sponsored health insurance

Retiring after 65

Avoiding coverage gaps and costly enrollment mistakes

Already on Medicare

Annual plan reviews, cost comparisons, and provider network checks

Under 65 with disability

Specialized Medicare support and plan options

Caregivers & family members

Clear guidance to help you understand benefits and coverage changes

Turning 65

First-time enrollment, deadlines, penalties, and choosing the right plan

Still working past 65

Coordinating Medicare with employer insurance

Retiring after 65

Avoiding gaps and costly mistakes

Already on Medicare

Annual reviews, cost comparisons, network checks

Under 65 with disability

Specialized support and plan options

Caregivers & family members

Help understanding benefits and coverage changes

Why Farmingdale Residents Choose Paul Barrett for Medicare

Unmatched Carrier Access

I’m an independent Medicare agent serving Farmingdale, NY, representing multiple Medicare Advantage and Medigap carriers, so my recommendations are based on your needs—not any single insurance company or commissions.

Education-First, No Pressure

I believe understanding your options is more important than a fast sale. You’ll know exactly what each plan covers and why it fits your health and budget.

Ongoing Support

My service doesn’t end after enrollment. Need help with claims, questions, or annual plan reviews? I’m here year-round for you.

Local Farmingdale Expertise

I work directly with Farmingdale residents and understand local doctors, hospital networks, and Medicare plan availability. Phone and Zoom consultations make getting expert Medicare help simple and convenient.

Medicare Advantage Plans in Farmingdale, NY

Farmingdale residents have access to a wide range of Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans offered by several insurance carriers across New York. These plans combine Medicare Part A (hospital) and Part B (medical) coverage, and many include prescription drug coverage (Part D) along with added benefits such as dental, vision, and hearing. Choosing the right Medicare Advantage plan in Farmingdale depends on your doctors, medications, preferred hospitals, and total out-of-pocket costs — not just the monthly premium.

I Represent These Top Medicare Advantage Carriers Serving Farmingdale:

UnitedHealthcare

One of the largest Medicare providers with broad network access.

Aetna

Competitive plan options with flexible benefits.

Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield

Comprehensive Medicare coverage with nationwide provider access.

EmblemHealth

Trusted New York-based health coverage.

Healthfirst

Leading New York community-focused health coverage.

WellCare

Affordable Medicare plans with extra benefits.

+ Additional carriers

More Medicare Advantage options available based on your ZIP code and eligibility.

Why So Many Plan Choices Matter

Not all Medicare Advantage plans are created equal. Some plans look attractive with $0 premiums but have limited doctor networks or poor customer service. Others may cost more monthly but save you thousands in out-of-pocket costs if you need care.
During our phone or Zoom consultation, here’s what I evaluate for you:

Does the plan include YOUR doctors and specialists?

Which hospitals are in-network (AFC Urgent Care Farmingdale, Doctor's Immediate Care, Archimed Medical Devices of USA, Accordis, etc.)?

What are the REAL out-of-pocket costs (copays, coinsurance, max limits)?

Are your prescriptions covered, and at what cost tier?

What extra benefits do you actually value (gym, dental, vision, OTC allowance)?

Does the carrier have good ratings for customer service and claims processing?

Overwhelmed by Choices?

Let me do the heavy lifting. I’ll compare all 50+ plans based on YOUR doctors, prescriptions, and budget—then present you with the top 2-3 options that make sense for your situation.

Medicare Supplement Plans in Farmingdale, NY

Prefer the freedom to see any doctor or specialist nationwide who accepts Medicare—no networks or referrals required? A Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan may be the right fit. New York offers standardized Medigap plans, and I work with 12+ top carriers to help Farmingdale residents find competitive rates and dependable coverage.

Farmingdale Medigap Carriers I Represent:

UnitedHealthcare (AARP)
Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield
EmblemHealth
Healthfirst
Aetna
WellCare
Additional Carriers
Multiple carriers = competitive rates and more stable pricing over time.

Farmingdale Unique Medigap Advantages

Understanding Medigap Pricing in Farmingdale

Guaranteed Issue Rights

Important: While age doesn’t affect Medigap pricing in New York, premiums can still change due to inflation and rising healthcare costs. That’s why I help you focus on carriers with strong rate stability and long-term value.

Most Popular Medigap Plans for Farmingdale Residents

Medigap Plan G

Comprehensive Coverage

Plan G is the most popular Medigap option among New York Medicare beneficiaries. After you meet the annual Part B deductible, this plan covers nearly all Medicare-approved expenses — with no copays, no coinsurance, and no unexpected bills.

Best for: Those who want predictable medical costs and the highest level of coverage.

High-Deductible Medigap Plan G

Smart Savings

This plan offers the same benefits as standard Plan G but with a significantly lower monthly premium. You pay the annual deductible first, and once it’s met, Medicare-approved costs are covered at 100%.

Best for: Healthy individuals who want strong catastrophic protection while keeping monthly premiums low.

Medigap Plan N

Balanced Coverage Option

Plan N features lower premiums than Plan G, with modest cost-sharing such as office visit and emergency room copays. It’s a great middle-ground option for those comfortable with small out-of-pocket expenses.

Best for: Those looking to balance premium savings with solid nationwide coverage.

Want to See Actual Rates?

I’ll show you side-by-side pricing from multiple carriers so you can make an informed decision. Most people are surprised by how affordable Medigap can be—

Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans in Farmingdalea, NY

Farmingdale residents can choose from multiple standalone Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans each year. If you have Original Medicare with a Medigap plan, you’ll need a separate Part D plan to cover your prescription medications. Because Part D plans change their pricing and drug coverage annually, choosing the right plan in Farmingdale, NY can make a significant difference in your total healthcare costs.

Finding the Right Part D Plan

The “best” Part D plan isn’t the one with the lowest premium—it’s the one that covers YOUR specific medications at the lowest total annual cost. A plan with a $0 premium might cost you hundreds more in copays if your drugs are on higher tiers.

I'll Help You Compare:

Important: Part D plans can change their formularies (drug lists) each year. It’s worth reviewing your plan annually to make sure you’re still getting the best value.
Bring me your prescription list and I’ll run a personalized analysis to find the Part D plan that saves you the most money.

Free Consultation

We’ll meet by phone or Zoom—whatever’s most comfortable for you. No cost, no obligation.

Understand Your Needs

I’ll ask about your doctors, prescriptions, budget, and health priorities. The more I know, the better I can help.

Compare Your Options

I’ll show you side-by-side comparisons of the plans that fit your situation—from all carriers I represent, not just one company.

Enroll with Confidence

Once you’ve chosen the right plan, I’ll handle the enrollment paperwork and make sure everything is submitted correctly.

Ongoing Support

Your coverage starts, and I remain your resource for questions, claims issues, or annual reviews. I’m here for the long haul.

How Working with Paul Barrett Works

Free Consultation — Start With a Personalized Review

No cost, no obligation

Understand Your Needs

I ask about your doctors, medications, budget, and health priorities

Compare Your Options

I compare plans from all carriers I represent (not just one)

Enroll with Confidence

You get simple side-by-side options tailored to you

Ongoing Support

I handle enrollment paperwork and ongoing support

All of This Costs You $0

You may be wondering how this service is free. The answer is simple: I’m paid by the insurance carriers when you enroll, not by you. Your plan costs the same whether you enroll on your own or work with me. The difference is guidance. With me, you get expert help, access to multiple carriers, and ongoing support—so you’re never left figuring things out alone.

Common Medicare Questions from Farmingdale Residents

Get answers to the questions I hear most often from Medicare beneficiaries in Farmingdale

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Medicare Advantage plans often have lower monthly premiums and extra benefits, but use provider networks. Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans offer more flexibility to see any doctor who accepts Medicare, with higher monthly premiums. The right choice depends on your doctors, health needs, and budget.
Plan options vary by Farmingdale neighborhood because Medicare plans are based on county, ZIP code, provider networks, and local hospital participation.
You can check if your doctor or hospital is in-network on a Medicare Advantage plan in Farmingdale, NY by using the plan’s provider search tool or contacting the plan directly.
Yes. The shingles vaccine is covered under Medicare Part D. Coverage and out-of-pocket costs can vary by plan, which is why reviewing your Part D coverage is important.
Most people pay no premium for Part A if they’ve worked long enough. Part B has a monthly premium set by Medicare each year, along with deductibles and coinsurance. I’ll explain current costs and how they affect your overall plan choice.
Yes — I help all areas of Farmingdale, NY, including Cold Spring Harbor, Greenlawn, South Huntington, and the surrounding communities. My Medicare services are available throughout the entire Farmingdale area and nearby towns.
Yes — you can switch Medicare plans if you’re not happy, but usually only during specific enrollment periods (like Open Enrollment or Special Enrollment). Outside those times, changes are limited unless you qualify for a Special Enrollment due to certain life events.
In Farmingdale, NY many of the widely available Medicare Advantage plans (like Aetna and Anthem Blue Cross plans) tend to include Northwell-affiliated providers and Farmingdale Hospital in their networks, helping ensure access to major local hospitals. However, network participation varies by specific plan, so always verify that your preferred Farmingdale area hospitals and doctors are in-network before enrolling.

Important Deadlines

Turning 65?

You have 7 months to enroll (3 months before your birthday, your birthday month, and 3 months after)

Annual Enrollment Period

October 15 - December 7 for coverage starting January 1

Medicare Advantage OEP

January 1 - March 31 to switch Medicare Advantage plans

What Farmingdale Clients Say

Real stories from real people who found the right Medicare coverage with Paul’s help.

“I was turning 65 and felt completely overwhelmed.”
“I live in Farmingdale and had no idea where to start with Medicare. Between Advantage plans, supplements, and prescription drug coverage, everything felt overwhelming. Paul took the time to explain each option clearly and never rushed me. He reviewed my doctors, medications, and budget, then presented a few plans that truly made sense for my situation.
What I appreciated most was that I never felt pressured. I felt confident in my decision and knew exactly what I was enrolling in. I highly recommend working with him if you want honest, local Medicare guidance.”

— Patrick C.

Farmingdale, NY
“Switching plans was easier than I expected.”
“I was already on Medicare but unhappy with my coverage and rising costs. Paul reviewed my current plan, explained what wasn’t working, and showed me better options available here in Farmingdale, NY. He checked my prescriptions, made sure my doctors were in-network, and handled all the paperwork.
The entire process was smooth and stress-free. I now have better coverage and lower out-of-pocket costs. It’s a huge relief knowing I have someone local I can call anytime I have questions.”

— Mary

Farmingdale, NY

About Paul Barrett — Your Farmingdale Medicare Expert

18+ Years

Experience

18+

Years Experience

5,000+

Clients Served

10+

10+ Medicare Advantage Carriers

12+

Medigap Carriers

I’ve been helping people navigate Medicare since 2007 — nearly two decades of staying on top of constant changes, new plans, and evolving Medicare rules. During that time, I’ve personally helped more than 5,000 Medicare beneficiaries find coverage that fits both their healthcare needs and their budget.
What makes my approach different is independence. I don’t work for any single insurance company. I represent over 10 Medicare Advantage carriers and more than 12 Medigap carriers, which allows me to provide truly unbiased guidance. My responsibility is to you — not to sales quotas or corporate targets.

I believe in education over pressure. My role isn’t to sell you something you don’t need; it’s to help you understand your Medicare options so you can make a confident, informed decision. Some clients need a quick conversation, while others prefer to review options over multiple calls. Either way, I work at your pace.

When you work with me, you’re not just getting help during enrollment. I’m available year-round to assist with claims questions, coverage changes, and annual plan reviews. Medicare is complex — and having a knowledgeable, local expert on your side makes all the difference.

— Paul Barrett

The Modern Medicare Agency
Scroll to Top

Request a Callback with
Paul Barrett

Fill out the form below, and we'll call you within 24 hours.