· @Paul
The short answer: 17 Medicare Advantage plans offered in Brooklyn in 2026 are leaving for 2027: 8 standard plans and 9 Special Needs Plans. 11 of them ended, so members must pick a new plan. 6 merged into another plan, so members are moved automatically. The largest change: Wellcare Simple (HMO-POS), one of Brooklyn’s most popular plans, merges into Wellcare Fidelis Simple, so its members are moved automatically. Choose by December 7 for the smoothest start. If your plan ended, you also have a backup: a Special Enrollment Period through the end of February 2027.
Brooklyn’s 2027 changes are different from the rest of New York
If you live in Brooklyn and you’re on a Medicare Advantage plan, the news you’re hearing on TV may not match what’s happening here. Some plans that are disappearing elsewhere in New York are staying in Brooklyn, and some Brooklyn plans are changing in ways the national stories don’t mention.
First, the reassuring part: your Medicare Part A and Part B continue no matter what. What may be ending is the private plan you picked to handle that coverage. Here’s the full Brooklyn list, what it means for you, and exactly what to do, in plain English.
I recently spoke with David Olson of Newsday about these changes for his article, “Medicare Advantage options narrow as insurers cut back.” Here’s what I told him:
Some Long Islanders “have been dropped two or three consecutive years, and it’s hard for them to comprehend why this keeps happening.” — Paul Barrett, as quoted in Newsday
Newsday was writing about Long Island, but I’m hearing the same thing from Brooklyn. Since Open Enrollment began on October 15, my office has averaged 63 calls a day, and about 4 of them, every single day, come from someone whose plan is ending. Some didn’t know until they called. You can read more about my Newsday interview here.
A real Brooklyn story: “I just want to pick a plan and stop worrying”
One of my Brooklyn clients, Mr. P., has now had to change his Medicare Advantage plan three years in a row. Aetna, UnitedHealthcare and now Humana: each time, the plan he chose didn’t last. When we spoke this fall, he told me he wishes he could just pick a plan and not have to worry about it every year. And like many of my clients, he simply can’t afford the extra monthly cost of a Medicare Supplement, which would avoid this problem.
I understand his frustration completely. Here’s the honest truth: no one can promise that any Medicare Advantage plan will be around next year. Insurance companies decide that, not you and not me. What I can promise Mr. P., and you, is this:
- We’ll choose the plan that fits his doctors, his prescriptions and his budget right now.
- I’ll check his plan every fall, so he never gets caught off guard by a letter.
- If his situation changes, New York lets him apply for a Medicare Supplement any time of year, with no health questions. That door stays open.
You shouldn’t have to carry this alone every October. That’s my job.
Got a letter about your plan? Let’s talk it through. Pick a time that works for you on my calendar, for a full plan review or just a quick call to ask questions. It’s free, and there’s no pressure. Schedule your free call with Paul
Brooklyn by the numbers
|
|
|---|---|
Plans leaving Brooklyn for 2027 | 17 (8 standard, 9 Special Needs Plans) |
Plans that ended (members must choose) | 11 |
Plans that merged (members moved automatically) | 6 |
Standard Medicare Advantage plans for 2027 | 37 |
2027 standard plans with a $0 monthly premium | 22 |
Companies offering standard plans in Brooklyn for 2027 | 11 |
Brooklyn residents in standard Medicare Advantage plans | about 61,500 |
Source: CMS 2027 Plan Crosswalk and Medicare Advantage Landscape files for Kings County.
The complete list: plans leaving Brooklyn for 2027
Find your plan’s name and ID on your member card. The ID starts with “H” followed by four numbers. Then look for it below.
Standard Medicare Advantage plans leaving (8)
Company | Plan name | Plan ID | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
Wellcare | Wellcare Simple (HMO-POS) | H4868-019 | Merged into Wellcare Fidelis Simple (HMO-POS). You’re moved automatically. |
Wellcare | Wellcare Assist (HMO-POS) | H4868-016 | Merged into Wellcare Fidelis Assist (HMO-POS). You’re moved automatically. |
Aetna | Aetna Medicare Enhanced Extra (PPO) | H5521-664 | Merged into Aetna Medicare Enhanced (PPO), H5521-661. You’re moved automatically. |
Humana | Humana Direct Choice Giveback (PPO) | H5970-031 | Ended. You must choose a new plan. |
Humana | Humana Gold Plus Giveback H3533-027 (HMO) | H3533-027 | Ended. You must choose a new plan. |
HealthSpring | HealthSpring True Choice (PPO) | H7849-150 | Ended. You must choose a new plan. |
Elderplan | Elderplan Flex (HMO-POS) | H3347-016 | Ended. You must choose a new plan. |
Elderplan | Elderplan Extra Help (HMO-POS) | H3347-009 | Ended. You must choose a new plan. |
Special Needs Plans leaving (9)
These plans are for people who have both Medicare and Medicaid, or who qualify for extra help.
Company | Plan name | Plan ID | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
Wellcare | Wellcare Dual Access (HMO D-SNP) | H4868-004 | Merged into Wellcare Fidelis Dual Access (HMO D-SNP). Moved automatically. |
Wellcare | Wellcare Dual Access (HMO D-SNP) | H4868-014 | Merged into Wellcare Fidelis Dual Access (HMO D-SNP). Moved automatically. |
Anthem | Anthem HealthPlus Full Dual Advantage LTSS (HMO D-SNP) | H8432-041 | Merged into Anthem HealthPlus Full Dual Advantage LTSS 2. Moved automatically. |
Wellcare | Wellcare Fidelis Dual Liberty Sync (HMO D-SNP) | H5599-013 | Ended. Choose a new plan. A new plan with the same name and a different ID is offered for 2027. |
Aetna | Aetna Medicare Partial Dual Care (HMO D-SNP) | H3312-090 | Ended. Choose a new plan. |
EmblemHealth | EmblemHealth VIP Dual (HMO D-SNP) | H5991-012 | Ended. Choose a new plan. |
EmblemHealth | EmblemHealth VIP Dual Enhanced (HMO D-SNP) | H5991-013 | Ended. Choose a new plan. |
EmblemHealth | EmblemHealth VIP Dual Reserve (HMO D-SNP) | H5991-010 | Ended. Choose a new plan. |
Humana | Humana Gold Plus SNP-DE H3533-034 (HMO D-SNP) | H3533-034 | Ended. Choose a new plan. |
A note for veterans and anyone in a plan without drug coverage: the public crosswalk data doesn’t track plans that don’t include prescriptions. If you’re in one of these plans, check the letter your plan sent you this fall to see whether it continues.
What changed, company by company
Company | What’s happening in Brooklyn for 2027 |
|---|---|
Wellcare | Its two HMO-POS plans, including the popular Wellcare Simple, merge into Wellcare Fidelis plans. Unlike in Westchester and Suffolk, all three Wellcare “Open” PPOs stay in Brooklyn. |
Humana | Both Humana “Giveback” plans end in Brooklyn, along with one Special Needs Plan. HumanaChoice H5970-028 (PPO), Humana Gold Plus H3533-033 and H3533-035 (HMOs), and Humana USAA Honor Giveback stay. |
HealthSpring (formerly Cigna) | Leaving New York entirely. HealthSpring True Choice (PPO) ends. |
Aetna | Aetna Medicare Enhanced Extra (PPO) merges into Aetna Medicare Enhanced (PPO). Watch the out-of-pocket limit: it rises from $6,750 to $9,850. One Special Needs Plan ends. |
EmblemHealth | Three Special Needs Plans end, but it adds three new HMOs: VIP Core, VIP Saver and VIP Value. |
Elderplan | Both standard HMO-POS plans end. Its Special Needs Plans continue. |
Devoted Health | New to Brooklyn for 2027, with three $0-premium PPOs. |
What’s still available in Brooklyn for 2027
Brooklyn still has plenty of choices: 37 standard Medicare Advantage plans from 11 companies (Aetna, Anthem, Devoted Health, EmblemHealth, Healthfirst, Humana, MetroPlus, UnitedHealthcare, VillageCareMAX, VNS Health and Wellcare).
Plan type | Plans | $0 premium | Without drug coverage |
|---|---|---|---|
HMO | 15 | 6 | 0 |
PPO | 14 | 11 | 2 |
HMO-POS | 8 | 5 | 3 |
Total | 37 | 22 | 5 |
The number to check before you switch
Every Medicare Advantage plan has a yearly out-of-pocket maximum: the most you’d pay for covered medical care in a bad year. The federal limit for 2027 is $9,850.
2027 out-of-pocket maximum | Brooklyn standard plans |
|---|---|
At the $9,850 federal limit | 25 of 37 |
Below the limit | 12 of 37 |
Lowest available | $4,950 (a veterans plan with no drug coverage) |
If you’re being moved automatically
“Merged” doesn’t mean “the same.” Here’s what changes for each Brooklyn plan being folded into another one for 2027:
Your 2026 plan | You’re moved into | 2027 monthly premium | Drug deductible | Yearly out-of-pocket limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Wellcare Simple (HMO-POS) | Wellcare Fidelis Simple (HMO-POS) | $0 (no change) | $615 → $700 | $9,250 → $9,850 |
Wellcare Assist (HMO-POS) | Wellcare Fidelis Assist (HMO-POS) | $0 | $590 → $700 | $9,250 → $9,850 |
Aetna Medicare Enhanced Extra (PPO) | Aetna Medicare Enhanced (PPO) | $79 | $615 → $700 | $6,750 → $9,850 |
Wellcare Dual Access (HMO D-SNP) | Wellcare Fidelis Dual Access (HMO D-SNP) | $0 (no change) | $410 or $615 → $700 | $9,250 → $9,850 |
Anthem HealthPlus Full Dual Advantage LTSS (HMO D-SNP) | Anthem HealthPlus Full Dual Advantage LTSS 2 (HMO D-SNP) | $40.50* | $615 → $700 | $9,250 → $9,850 |
*Most members with Medicaid or Extra Help don’t pay this premium. Check your letter. On the plus side, the Anthem plan you’re moving into is rated 5 stars by Medicare.
The biggest jump is for Aetna Medicare Enhanced Extra members: your worst-case yearly cost rises by $3,100. If you have ongoing health needs, compare that against your other options before December 7.
Source: CMS 2027 Plan Crosswalk and plan landscape data for Kings County.
“I never got a letter!” and other mail mix-ups
This fall I’ve talked with people who swear they never received a letter about their plan. Others got a letter from their insurance company and, the very same day, a glossy postcard from that same company advertising other plans. In Brooklyn it’s even more confusing, because six plans are merging: some of you got a letter saying you’re being “moved,” not “ended.”
You’re not alone. In a 2025 survey of more than 1,500 people with Medicare, 24% said they don’t remember ever getting their Annual Notice of Change, according to eHealth, as reported by AJMC.
If you never got a letter
- Call the member services number on the back of your card and ask, “Is my plan continuing in 2027, ending, or being merged?”
- Match your plan ID (on your card) to the lists above.
- Look up your plan for 2027 on Medicare.gov’s Plan Finder.
- Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), any time, day or night.
- Or book a quick call with me. I can check your plan’s status in a few minutes.
Missing the letter doesn’t take away your rights. If your plan ended, you still have the same deadlines and the same Special Enrollment Period.
How to tell your mail apart
What you got | What it really is | What to do |
|---|---|---|
A letter saying your plan won’t continue in 2027 | Your official non-renewal notice. Your plan ended. | Choose a new plan, ideally by December 7. |
A letter saying you’re being “moved” or “transitioned” to a different plan | Your plan merged. You’ll be switched automatically on January 1. | Check the new plan’s doctors, drugs and costs. You’re allowed to choose a different plan. |
An Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) | A summary of how your continuing plan changes next year | Read it. Check your doctors, drugs and out-of-pocket limit. |
A glossy postcard or brochure about “new plans” | An advertisement. It doesn’t change your coverage. | Treat it as information only. Never enroll just because of an ad. |
A phone call saying “Medicare” is calling about your plan | Usually a sales call, not Medicare | Medicare won’t call you to sell a plan. Hang up and call a source you trust. |
Paul’s Honest Take: Getting a cancellation letter and an ad from the same company on the same day is confusing by design. My rule is simple: nothing changes your coverage except an enrollment you choose yourself, or an automatic merge your plan told you about in writing. A postcard can’t enroll you, and neither can a phone call you didn’t agree to.
If your plan is on the list, here’s what to do
Step 1: Find out if your plan “ended” or “merged”
Your letter says | What it means | What you need to do |
|---|---|---|
Your plan is not renewing (a non-renewal notice) | Your coverage ends December 31, 2026 | Choose a new plan. If you do nothing, you won’t be moved into one. |
You’re being moved to a different plan (an Annual Notice of Change) | The company moves you automatically on January 1 | Nothing is required, but check that your doctors, drugs and costs still work. You can still switch. |
Step 2: Know your deadlines
Date | What you can do |
|---|---|
Now through December 7, 2026 | Open Enrollment. Choose any plan. Coverage starts January 1. |
December 8 through the end of February 2027 | Special Enrollment Period, only for people whose plan ended. Choose in December and coverage starts January 1. Choose later and it starts the first of the next month. |
January 1 through March 31, 2027 | If you’re in any Medicare Advantage plan, you get one more chance to switch plans or go back to Original Medicare. |
Any time of year (New York only) | Apply for a Medicare Supplement plan. |
Step 3: Understand what happens if you do nothing
If your plan ended and you don’t choose a new one, on January 1 you’ll be on Original Medicare only (here’s my full guide to what to do when a plan is discontinued):
- No drug coverage. Your prescriptions won’t be covered until you join a drug plan, and going too long without one can mean a Part D late penalty that lasts for life.
- No yearly cap on costs. Original Medicare alone has no out-of-pocket maximum.
- No extras. Dental, vision or hearing benefits from your old plan stop.
If you have Medicare and Medicaid and were in a Special Needs Plan that ended, call your plan or HIICAP right away. Your Medicaid benefits continue, but how they’re coordinated with Medicare may change.
Step 4: Consider every option, including a supplement
New York is one of only two states where you can buy a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan any month of the year, with no health questions, and everyone in your area pays the same price regardless of age. (Here’s how New York’s supplement protections work.) My Brooklyn Medigap guide compares current supplement prices for Brooklyn.
| Another Medicare Advantage plan | Original Medicare + a supplement + a drug plan |
|---|---|---|
Monthly cost | Often low or $0 | Higher |
Costs when you get care | Copays, up to a yearly cap (as high as $9,850) | Very little |
Doctors and hospitals | Usually a network | Any provider that takes Medicare |
Drug coverage | Usually built in | Separate Part D plan |
Extras like dental and vision | Often included | Not included |
Step 5: Check your doctors and hospitals first
Brooklyn’s hospitals don’t all work with every plan. Before you choose, confirm that your doctors and the hospital you’d use in an emergency are in the new plan’s 2027 network. That might be NYU Langone Hospital–Brooklyn, NewYork-Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist, Maimonides (now joining NYC Health + Hospitals), NYC Health + Hospitals/Kings County or South Brooklyn Health, Mount Sinai Brooklyn, SUNY Downstate or a One Brooklyn Health hospital. Call the plan or your doctor’s office; don’t rely on an online directory alone.
Have your doctors and prescriptions handy? I’ll check every plan for you. Bring your list, and we’ll compare all 37 Brooklyn plans together, side by side, including any Medicare Supplement options. Book your free plan review
Paul’s Honest Take
The biggest Brooklyn story this year isn’t a plan disappearing. It’s thousands of Brooklyn residents being moved into a plan they didn’t pick. If you’re in Wellcare Simple, “automatic” doesn’t mean “the same.” Open the letter, check that your doctors and pharmacy are still in network, and compare the new plan to what else is out there. If your plan ended, take a breath: you have until the end of February, and Brooklyn has 37 other plans to choose from. Don’t let a phone call from someone you’ve never met rush you. The right plan depends on your doctors, your drugs and your budget, not on who called you first.
Let’s sort it out together, no pressure
I answer my own phone. No call centers, no hand-offs. As an independent broker, I work with many insurance companies, so my job is to lay out your options, not push one plan. For 2027, I work with 10 of the 11 companies offering Medicare Advantage in Brooklyn and can offer 36 of the borough’s 37 standard plans. If a plan I don’t offer turns out to be your best fit, I’ll tell you, and point you to Medicare.gov to enroll. My help costs you nothing.
- Call or text: 631-358-5793
- Email: medicare@paulbinsurance.com
- Schedule a free review or a quick call on my personal calendar, whichever you need: Pick a time with Paul
- Learn at your own pace: Free Medicare guides and my weekly no-sales-pitch newsletter
Frequently asked questions
How many Medicare Advantage plans are leaving Brooklyn in 2027?
17 plans offered in Brooklyn (Kings County) in 2026 won’t be offered there in 2027: 8 standard plans and 9 Special Needs Plans. 11 ended and 6 merged into another plan.
I’m in Wellcare Simple. Do I need to do anything?
You’ll be moved automatically into Wellcare Fidelis Simple (HMO-POS) on January 1, 2027. You don’t have to act, but you should check your Annual Notice of Change to confirm your doctors, pharmacy and drugs are covered. You can still choose a different plan through December 7.
Are the Wellcare PPOs leaving Brooklyn?
No. Wellcare Giveback Open, Simple Open and Assist Open (PPOs) are leaving Westchester and Suffolk, but they’re still offered in Brooklyn for 2027.
What happened to Humana’s Giveback plans in Brooklyn?
Both end on December 31, 2026: Humana Direct Choice Giveback (PPO) and Humana Gold Plus Giveback H3533-027 (HMO). Members must choose a new plan. Humana still offers other plans in Brooklyn, including HumanaChoice H5970-028 (PPO).
Is HealthSpring leaving New York?
Yes. HealthSpring (the former Cigna Medicare plans) is leaving New York entirely, so HealthSpring True Choice (PPO) ends in Brooklyn.
Will I lose Medicare if my plan is cancelled?
No. Your Medicare Part A and Part B continue. Only the private plan ends. If you don’t choose a new one, you’ll be on Original Medicare with no drug coverage starting January 1.
Can I switch to a Medicare Supplement instead?
Yes. In New York you can apply for a Medicare Supplement plan any time of year, with no health questions. You’d also add a separate Part D drug plan.
Keep reading
If you want to… | Read this |
|---|---|
See everything that changed for 2027 | |
See which plans are leaving Westchester | |
Compare Medicare Supplement prices in Brooklyn | |
Learn New York’s special supplement rules | |
Avoid a lifelong drug penalty | |
Get local help |
Free, trusted resources
Resource | What it helps with | How to reach it |
|---|---|---|
Compare every 2027 plan in your ZIP code | 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) | |
Official Medicare Supplement prices for New York City | Online rate lookup | |
State help with prescription costs | 1-800-332-3742 | |
HIICAP (New York’s free Medicare counseling) | Unbiased one-on-one help | 1-800-701-0501 |
Sources
- CMS Medicare Advantage Landscape Source Files, 2026 and 2027
- CMS 2027 Plan Crosswalk (ended vs. merged status by plan)
- Medicare.gov Plan Finder
- NY Department of Financial Services, Medicare Supplement plans and rates
About the author
Paul Barrett, CMIP, is the founder and principal agent of The Modern Medicare Agency in Melville, NY, a small, family-owned agency. He’s an independent, Medicare-only broker with 18+ years of experience, AHIP-certified, licensed in 37 states and appointed with 40+ insurance companies. He has helped more than 5,000 clients, hosts the Wise Guys Retirement Talk podcast and wrote Medicare Mastery Unlocked.
NPN 5316441 · 445 Broad Hollow Rd, Melville, NY 11747 · 631-358-5793 · medicare@paulbinsurance.com
Last reviewed: November 2026. Plan information is for the 2027 plan year and can change. Always confirm details for your ZIP code.
Important disclosures
We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 10 organizations which offer 36 products in Kings County. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.
Paul Barrett and The Modern Medicare Agency are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. This article is for educational purposes and is not a recommendation of any specific plan. Plan availability, benefits, premiums and networks vary by county and ZIP code and may change each year. Enrollment in some plans is limited to certain times of the year unless you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period. Special Needs Plans are available only to people who meet eligibility requirements. Paul Barrett is a licensed insurance agent, NPN 5316441.




