Medicare Help
You Can Trust.

Huntington resident for over 25 years. Helping you

make confident, informed Medicare decisions since 2007.

Welcome to Huntington

Local Medicare Agent Serving Huntington, Northport, Greenlawn & Surrounding Areas

Paul Barrett

Founder

“I treat every appointment like a conversation at my own kitchen table.”

A Little About Me

I didn’t get into Medicare because it was easy — I got into it because it was confusing, even for insurance professionals. Early in my career, I saw too many people being pushed into plans that weren’t right for them simply because they were profitable. That never sat right with me.
I’ve lived in Huntington for over 25 years, and for nearly two decades I’ve helped neighbors, friends, and families here make Medicare decisions they actually feel good about. Most of my appointments feel more like a conversation at the kitchen table than a sales meeting.

Why Huntington Residents Choose Me

Many people come to me after feeling confused by mailers and TV ads. My clients choose me because they want clarity, honesty, and local experience — not a sales pitch.

Local Knowledge & Experience

Deep understanding of Huntington Hospital, Northwell Health, NYU Langone, and Optum Health networks. I know how these systems work with Medicare plans and how they change year to year.

Independent & Unbiased

I’m not tied to one insurance company. I compare plans across all carriers to find what fits YOU, not what a single company wants to sell.

Education-First Approach

I explain your options clearly, discuss the honest pros and cons, and never pressure you into a decision. You’re always in control.

Ongoing Local Support

I’m here year-round, not just during enrollment season. Questions? Billing concerns? I’m just a phone call away.

How I Compare Medicare Carriers

I don’t start with insurance company names — I start with you.

Before Recommending Any Plan

I take the time to understand:

Then I Compare Plans Across Carriers

Evaluating :

The goal isn't to find a "popular" plan — it's to find the plan that makes the most sense for you, now and in the future.

Medicare Advantage plans can be a good fit for some Huntington residents — especially those comfortable using provider networks and looking for lower monthly premiums.

What’s important to understand is that New York offers flexibility that many other states do not.

Important for Huntington Residents to Know:

  • You can switch from Medicare Advantage to a Medicare Supplement
  • You can move back and forth between plan types from one year to the next
  • No medical underwriting is required in New York

This means you are not locked into one plan type forever.

When reviewing Medicare Advantage plans, I help you evaluate:

  • Whether your doctors at Huntington Hospital / Northwell are in-network
  • Access to Northwell, NYU Langone, and Optum Health
  • Real out-of-pocket costs — not just the advertised premium
  • How referrals and prior authorizations work locally
  • Whether the plan fits your needs today and long-term

Medicare Supplement plans are popular with Huntington residents who value predictability and freedom of choice.

With a Medigap plan, you can see any doctor nationwide who accepts Medicare, with no referrals and no network restrictions.

An Honest New York Reality

Because New York has guaranteed issue and community-rated Medigap laws, there are usually fewer meaningful pricing differences between insurance companies.

In most cases:

  • Only one or two carriers are competitively priced at a given time
  • The plan letter (G, N, or High Deductible G) matters more than the company name
  • Carrier competitiveness can change over time

My role:

Help you choose the right structure, identify the best-priced option today, and discuss long-term rate considerations — not overwhelm you with logos.

Many Huntington residents receive care outside of town — or even outside New York. Some see specialists elsewhere on Long Island, some travel frequently, and others live part of the year in another state. If where you receive care — in New York or across the country — matters to you, we plan for that.

I help you understand:

  • Which plans offer broader provider access
  • How out-of-area and out-of-state care works
  • When a Medicare Supplement may be the better fit
  • When a Medicare Advantage PPO may still make sense

The goal is simple:

Your coverage should work where you actually receive care — not just where you live.

Prescription drug coverage is often where Medicare becomes most confusing.

I help Huntington residents compare Part D plans by reviewing:

  • Your specific medications
  • Preferred pharmacies (CVS, Walgreens, and local Huntington pharmacies)
  • Total annual drug costs
  • Coverage gap exposure
  • Year-to-year plan changes

Plans change every year. Annual reviews help prevent surprises.

Who I Help in Huntington

I work with Medicare consumers at every stage of the journey
Turning 65 — enrolling correctly and avoiding penalties
Still working past 65 — coordinating Medicare with employer coverage
Retiring or losing employer insurance — preventing gaps in coverage
Already on Medicare — reviewing plans, networks, and costs
Traveling frequently or living part-time out-of-state
Caregivers & family members — helping parents make confident decisions

Common Medicare Mistakes I See in Huntington, NY

A simple, straightforward process

Getting the Same Plan as a Friend

Your neighbor's plan might be completely wrong for your prescriptions, doctors, or health needs. Medicare is never one-size-fits-all.

Assuming Doctors Are "Automatically" In-Network

Just because your doctor is affiliated with Northwell doesn't mean they accept every Northwell-related plan. Many Huntington residents learn this the hard way.

Getting the Same Plan as a Friend

Your neighbor's plan might be completely wrong for your prescriptions, doctors, or health needs. Medicare is never one-size-fits-all.

Not Reviewing Part D Plans Annually

Medications and formularies change every year. A plan that works well this year may become expensive next year.

Believing You're Locked In Forever

In New York, you have more flexibility than you realize — including unique Medigap protections other states don't offer.

Relying on TV Ads Instead of Local Guidance

National marketing doesn't reflect Huntington's doctor networks, hospital affiliations, or local plan availability.

My job is to help you avoid these mistakes before they cost you. I review your doctors, prescriptions, hospitals, budget, and personal preferences — so we choose a plan that fits you, not the one-size-fits-all plans advertised on TV.

Access to Major Medicare Carriers

As an independent broker, I objectively compare plans from major insurance companies to recommend what fits you — not what a single company wants to sell.

What Huntington Residents Are Saying

“I had done quite a bit of research on Medicare Supplement plans, but Paul explained things I didn’t even know to look for. He helped me understand my options clearly and guided me to the best plan for my needs and budget. His knowledge of Medicare and his professionalism made the entire process stress-free. I’m grateful for his support — thank you, Paul!”

Donna F.

Huntington, NY
“Paul Barrett was incredibly helpful, patient, and knowledgeable during our Medicare review. He took the time to answer all of my questions and guided me and my husband through the process step-by-step. Thanks to Paul, we enrolled in the Medicare plan that truly fits our needs. I highly recommend him to anyone looking for honest, expert Medicare guidance.”

Ronnie S.

Huntington, NY
“Before calling Paul, Medicare Advantage felt like an alphabet soup of networks and rules. Paul spent over an hour with me—patiently breaking down the differences between HMO and PPO plans and explaining everything in a way that finally made sense. He helped me choose a low-premium Medicare Advantage plan that included my primary care doctor. Five stars for Paul’s clarity, expertise, and patience!”

Larry T.

Huntington, NY
“The Modern Medicare Agency provided exceptional service. Their explanations of Medicare Supplement plans, policies, and rates were clear and easy to understand, which made choosing the right coverage simple. Their knowledgeable local Medicare agents in Huntington guided me through every step of the enrollment process. Working with their team was truly a breeze — highly recommended.”

Michelle D.

Huntington, NY
“Paul Barrett provided amazing care and attention while helping me navigate the tricky process of finding the right Medicare Supplement plan for my needs. He handled every detail with professionalism and made the entire experience stress-free.”

Lawrence W.

Huntington, NY

How Working With Me Works

A simple, straightforward process

Free Consultation

Phone, Zoom, or in-home visit for Huntington residents

Understand Your Needs

Doctors, prescriptions, budget, and priorities

Compare Your Options

Clear side-by-side explanations in plain English

Enroll With Confidence

I handle the paperwork and confirm everything

Ongoing Support

Questions, reviews, concerns — year-round

Many clients appreciate being able to sit at their own kitchen table, ask questions, and never feel rushed.

Get Local Medicare Help You Can Trust

If you live in Huntington, NY and want guidance from someone who understands both Medicare and the local healthcare landscape, I’d be happy to help.

In-Home Visits

Available for Huntington
Residents

No pressure, no obligation. Let's talk about your Medicare options.

Scroll to Top

Request a Callback with
Paul Barrett

Fill out the form below, and we'll call you within 24 hours.