Your annual Medicare plan review is a once-a-year check that your coverage still fits your health, your prescriptions and your budget. Do it during Open Enrollment, which runs every year from October 15 through December 7, because that is the window when you can switch and when changes generally take effect January 1. If you review your plan and still like it, you don’t have to do anything. If something changed, you have a short window to fix it.
This guide walks through what to read, what to compare, which dates matter, and what to do if your plan no longer works for you.
TL;DR
- Medicare plans can change every year, so review yours each fall. Costs, benefits and provider networks can all shift.
- Start with the Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) your plan mails, generally in September. It tells you what changes in January.
- Check four things: your drugs, your doctors, your total yearly cost and any extra benefits you actually use.
- Open Enrollment is October 15 to December 7. If you are happy with your plan, no action is needed.
- Not sure what you are looking at? An independent agent can run the comparison with you at no cost to you.
Table of Contents
- Do you really need to review your plan every year?
- Your annual review timeline
- Step 1: Read your Annual Notice of Change
- Step 2: Compare your plan against the alternatives
- Step 3: Decide: keep, tweak or switch
- What if your plan no longer meets your needs?
- If you’re new to Medicare or leaving employer coverage
- Perspective: why we treat the review as a checkup
- Get a second set of eyes on your review
- A simple review checklist
- FAQ
- Sources
Do you really need to review your plan every year?
Yes. Medicare.gov says costs, benefits and the providers a plan works with can change each year, so a plan that was a good fit last January may not be a good fit next January. Your own situation changes too: a new medication, a new specialist, a move, or a change in income.
The good news is that the review is often short. If you read your notice, compare a few options and find your current plan still meets your needs, you keep it and your coverage continues automatically. Approved changes to cost or benefits still begin January 1, which is exactly why you read the notice first.
The costly mistake is not a bad choice. It is no choice: letting a plan renew without reading what changed, then finding out in February that your drug moved to a higher tier or your doctor left the network.
Your annual review timeline
Most of the work happens in a few weeks, and it helps to work backward from the deadline.
| When | What to do |
|---|---|
| September | Look for your plan’s ANOC in the mail or your online account |
| October 1 | Medicare.gov says this is when to review plan notices and preview options |
| October 15 to December 7 | Open Enrollment: join, switch or drop a Medicare Advantage or Part D plan |
| December 7 | Your plan must receive your enrollment request by this date |
| January 1 | Changes made during Open Enrollment generally take effect |
| January 1 to March 31 | Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment for people already in an Advantage plan |
If you are reading this in late October, you are inside the window with weeks to spare. Don’t wait for the last week, though. Pharmacies, doctors’ offices and plans are all busiest in early December, and a rushed comparison is how people end up with the wrong plan.
Step 1: Read your Annual Notice of Change
The ANOC is the most useful piece of mail you will get from your plan all year. Medicare.gov says plans must send it each fall, generally in September, and it describes the coverage and cost changes taking effect in January.
When you open it, look for:
- Premium changes. Did your monthly premium go up or down?
- Deductibles and copays. Check doctor visits, specialist visits, hospital stays and any drug tiers you use.
- Out-of-pocket maximum. For Medicare Advantage, this is your protection in a bad year.
- Drug formulary changes. Is every medication you take still covered, and on the same tier?
- Network changes. Are your doctors and hospital still in?
- Extra benefits. Dental, vision, hearing, over-the-counter allowances and fitness benefits can be added or removed.
We have a plain-English walkthrough of the notice in our guide to the Medicare Annual Notice of Change explained for 2026, plus tips for reviewing your annual Medicare notice. If you want a printable worksheet, our Medicare Annual Enrollment Period checklist covers the same ground.
Step 2: Compare your plan against the alternatives
Reading the notice tells you what is changing. It does not tell you whether something else is now better. For that, you compare.
Medicare.gov’s Plan Compare tool lets you compare plans side by side, estimate total out-of-pocket costs, enter your drugs and preferred pharmacies, check provider networks and see quality ratings. Medicare.gov’s tools page adds that you can enter your prescriptions to estimate monthly and yearly costs for Medicare Advantage and Part D plans.
Here is what to compare, depending on your coverage.
If you have a Part D drug plan
The Idaho Department of Insurance’s Open Enrollment teaching materials list what Part D shoppers should check: the formulary, prior authorization, step therapy, quantity limits, premiums, deductibles, copays or coinsurance, preferred pharmacies, mail order, star ratings, and whether the plan works alongside any retiree coverage.
In practice, that means a drug-by-drug check. List every prescription, with dose and how often you fill it. Enter them all, including the cheap generics, because the total is what matters. A plan with a low premium can cost more overall if your key drug sits on a high tier or requires step therapy. Our Part D drug coverage guide shows how to compare plans step by step, and our Medicare Part D page explains how we help.
If you have a Medicare Advantage plan
The same Idaho materials say Advantage shoppers should look at the premium, deductible, cost sharing, annual maximum out-of-pocket amount, service area, provider and hospital networks, access rules, prescription rules and extra benefits.
Two items deserve extra attention:
- Your doctors. Call the office and ask whether they will be in the plan’s network for next year. Don’t rely only on an online directory.
- Your worst-case cost. A low copay on primary care means little if you have a hospital stay and the maximum out-of-pocket is high.
If you recurring screenings or imaging matter to you, check how often your plan covers them. Understanding how often DEXA scans are recommended can help you decide whether that coverage belongs on your checklist.
For a structured approach, see our simple 5-step guide to comparing Medicare Advantage plans.
If you have Original Medicare with a Medigap plan
Medigap does not have the same yearly formulary or network changes, since it works with any provider who accepts Medicare. Your yearly review is still worthwhile. Look at your premium increases over the last few years, whether you have Part D drug coverage alongside it, and whether the plan letter you chose still matches your needs. Our Medicare Supplement page and Medicare Supplement comparison guide explain the options. Because Medigap switching can involve health questions, talk to an agent before you cancel anything.
Step 3: Decide: keep, tweak or switch
After the comparison, you land in one of three places.

Keep it. Your drugs and doctors are covered, your costs are acceptable and nothing important changed. Medicare.gov says that if you remain satisfied, no action is needed.
Tweak it. Your medical plan is fine but your drug coverage is not, or the reverse. You may be able to change only one piece. Part D, for instance, can often be reviewed separately from the rest.
Switch it. During Open Enrollment you can join, switch or drop Medicare Advantage or Part D coverage, or switch to Original Medicare. Changes generally take effect January 1. Our guide on how to switch Medicare Advantage plans during Open Enrollment walks through the mechanics, and Can I change my Medicare plan? covers the other situations.
What if your plan no longer meets your needs?
Start by naming the problem. People tend to say “I’m unhappy with my plan” when the real issue is one of a short list.
| The problem | Where to look first |
|---|---|
| A drug got more expensive or was dropped | Part D or Advantage drug coverage for next year |
| Your doctor or hospital is leaving the network | Other plans that include them, or Original Medicare |
| Monthly premium keeps rising | Compare total yearly cost, not just premium |
| You need dental, vision or hearing | Plans with those benefits, or standalone coverage |
| You moved out of the service area | A plan available at your new address |
Then match the problem to the timing:
- Right now through December 7: Open Enrollment. This is your main window.
- January 1 to March 31: if you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, you can change plans or return to Original Medicare, with the change effective the first day of the month after the plan gets your request. Our Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment guide covers it in detail.
- Other times: certain life events, such as moving or losing other coverage, can open a Special Enrollment Period. The rules depend on the event, so confirm yours on Medicare.gov or with an agent before you assume you qualify.
If you are not satisfied but are unsure what to ask for, bring your ANOC, your drug list and your doctors’ names. Those three things are enough to start a real comparison.
If you’re new to Medicare or leaving employer coverage
The annual review is for people who already have a plan. If you are turning 65, the rules are different. Medicare’s Initial Enrollment Period generally surrounds your 65th birthday, and if you or your spouse have active employer coverage, a Special Enrollment Period may apply when that coverage or employment ends. The Medicare & You handbook explains the Part A, Part B and Part D enrollment rules and the possible late-enrollment penalties.
The same applies if you are under 65 and eligible through disability. In both cases, get your first plan right and then build the yearly review into your routine. An early mistake compounds, because some penalties last as long as you have coverage.
Perspective: why we treat the review as a checkup
We have helped Medicare consumers since 2007, and the pattern is consistent. People rarely choose a bad plan on purpose. They choose a good plan for the year they signed up and then never look again. Their health changes, their prescriptions change, the plan changes, and nobody connects the dots until a pharmacy counter surprise.
That is why we start with education. It is hard to make a good decision when you don’t understand your options, so we explain how the pieces fit before we talk about a plan. As independent agents we can compare across 40+ carriers instead of steering you to one company, and we do annual coverage checkups as part of the service. Sometimes the right answer is to keep exactly what you have, and we will say so.
Our advice for any review: look at the whole year’s cost, not the premium. Ask about your actual drugs and actual doctors. And give yourself enough time that no one is pressuring you.
— Paul
Get a second set of eyes on your review
If you would rather not do the comparison alone, we can do it with you. We are independent agents who compare plans across many carriers, and we review your notice, your medications and your doctors with you, then explain your options without pressure. Start with our Medicare Advantage plans or Part D prescription drug plans pages, or reach us from paulbinsurance.com.
If you also want to think beyond Medicare, we help with dental, final expense, long-term care and annuity questions. Your yearly review is a good moment to check those, too.
A simple review checklist
Before you decide, make sure you have done each of these:
- Read your ANOC from start to finish, not just the first page.
- Listed every prescription, dose and pharmacy.
- Confirmed each doctor and hospital is in network for next year.
- Compared total estimated yearly cost, including premiums, deductibles and the out-of-pocket maximum.
- Checked extra benefits you use (dental, vision, hearing, allowances).
- Confirmed the plan’s service area covers where you live.
- Made your change before December 7, or confirmed you are keeping your plan.
For a deeper look at why the yearly habit matters, see our simple guide to reviewing your Medicare plan annually.
FAQ
Do I need to review my Medicare plan every year?
Yes, you should. Medicare.gov says costs, benefits and providers can change each year, so reviewing your coverage during Open Enrollment is the safest habit. If your plan still meets your needs and you want to keep it, you generally don’t need to take any action.
When can I change my Medicare plan?
The main window is Open Enrollment, October 15 to December 7, with changes generally effective January 1. If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, you also have January 1 to March 31 to switch plans or return to Original Medicare. Other situations may qualify for a Special Enrollment Period.
What should I check when reviewing my coverage?
Start with the Annual Notice of Change from your plan. Then compare cost, prescription drug coverage, doctors in network and extra benefits. Medicare.gov’s Plan Compare tool lets you enter your drugs and pharmacies to estimate your total costs.
What happens if I do nothing?
If you take no action, your current coverage generally continues, and any changes your plan announced take effect January 1. That is fine if you read the notice and are comfortable with it. It is risky if you never opened it.
Can an agent help me with the review?
Yes. Independent agents can compare plans from multiple carriers, check your drugs and doctors and help with enrollment. Agents are typically paid by the insurance carrier when you enroll, so you don’t pay a separate fee for the comparison.
Sources
- Your Yearly Medicare Review (Medicare.gov)
- Remember Key Medicare Dates (Medicare.gov)
- Open Enrollment (Medicare.gov)
- Plan Annual Notice of Change (Medicare.gov)
- Helpful tools (Medicare.gov)
- Medicare & You handbook (Medicare.gov)
- Medicare Minute teaching materials (Idaho Department of Insurance)
Recommended
- Why It’s Important to Review Your Medicare Plan Annually for Optimal Coverage and Savings
- The 2026 Annual Medicare Plan Review Checklist: Your Guide to Peace of Mind
- Tips For Reviewing Your Annual Medicare Coverage: Essential Steps for Better Health Insurance Management
- Your Annual Enrollment Period Changes Checklist for 2026




