Last updated November 6, 2026. We’ll keep this guide current through February 28, 2027, as plan details are confirmed.
Nov 6, 2026 · @Paul
If you got a letter saying your Medicare Advantage plan is ending in 2027, take a breath. You have time, you have rights, and you have plenty of good options. A plan ending is not the same as losing your Medicare. Your Medicare stays. Only the plan around it changes.
This fall, several insurance companies are ending Medicare Advantage plans in Nassau and Suffolk counties. About 33,000 Long Islanders are enrolled in plans that won’t continue in 2027, according to Newsday. Since Open Enrollment began on October 15, my office has averaged 63 calls a day, and about 4 of them, every single day, come from someone whose plan is ending. Most are worried and unsure what to do. Some never even knew their plan was ending until they called. This guide walks you through exactly which plans are ending, how much time you have, and how to choose a new plan with confidence.
I recently spoke with David Olson of Newsday about these changes for his article, “Medicare Advantage options narrow as insurers cut back.” Here’s what I told him:
Some Long Islanders “have been dropped two or three consecutive years, and it’s hard for them to comprehend why this keeps happening.” — Paul Barrett, as quoted in Newsday
If that sounds like you, you’re not alone, and you’re not out of options. You can read more about my Newsday interview here.
The quick answer
Your question | The answer |
Is my Medicare ending? | No. Only your Medicare Advantage plan is ending. You still have Medicare. |
When should I choose a new plan? | By December 7, 2026, so your new plan starts January 1, 2027 with no gap. |
What if I miss December 7? | You get a Special Enrollment Period through February 28, 2027. |
What if I do nothing? | On January 1, you’ll be moved to Original Medicare, without drug coverage or your plan’s extras. |
Are there still good plans on Long Island? | Yes. Nassau has 28 standard Medicare Advantage plans for 2027 and Suffolk has 18. |
Can I switch to a Medicare Supplement instead? | Yes. In New York, you can apply for Medigap any time, with no health questions. |
Can someone help me for free? | Yes. My help is always free, and so is New York’s HIICAP counseling program. |
Got a letter that your plan is ending? Let’s talk it through. Pick a time that works for you on my calendar, for a full plan review or just a quick call to ask questions. It’s free, and there’s no pressure. Schedule your free call with Paul
Medicare Advantage plans ending in Nassau County for 2027
In Nassau, six Medicare Advantage plans from 2026 won’t be offered in 2027. Humana accounts for half of them.
Carrier | Plan name | Plan ID | Plan type |
Humana | Humana Direct Choice Giveback | H5970-032-0 | PPO |
Humana | HumanaChoice | H5970-029-0 | PPO |
Humana | Humana Gold Plus Giveback | H3533-027-0 | HMO |
UnitedHealthcare | AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC NY-0009 | H3379-043-0 | HMO-POS |
Aetna | Aetna Medicare Enhanced | H5521-665-0 | PPO |
HealthSpring | HealthSpring True Choice | H7849-150-0 | PPO |
HealthSpring True Choice is part of a bigger change: HealthSpring is leaving Medicare Advantage on Long Island entirely for 2027, in both Nassau and Suffolk.
There’s good news in Nassau, too. A new carrier, Devoted Health, is entering Nassau County for 2027 with three new plans. Nassau still has 28 standard Medicare Advantage plans to choose from, down only slightly from 31 in 2026.
Find your plan ID on your member card or on the letter your plan sent you. It starts with a letter and four numbers, like “H5970.” Matching the full ID is the surest way to know whether your plan is on this list. Plans with similar names may still be continuing.
Medicare Advantage plans ending in Suffolk County for 2027
Suffolk was hit hardest on PPO plans. Humana, Wellcare and HealthSpring have all dropped their PPO plans in Suffolk for 2027. In fact, HealthSpring is leaving Medicare Advantage on Long Island entirely for 2027. That leaves Aetna as the only carrier still offering PPO plans in Suffolk.
Carrier | Plan name | Plan ID | Plan type |
Humana | Humana Direct Choice Giveback | H5970-032-0 | PPO |
Humana | HumanaChoice | H5970-029-0 | PPO |
Humana | Humana Gold Plus Giveback | H3533-027-0 | HMO |
Wellcare | Wellcare Giveback Open | H2775-111-0 | PPO |
Wellcare | Wellcare Simple Open | H2775-106-0 | PPO |
Aetna | Aetna Medicare Enhanced | H5521-665-0 | PPO |
HealthSpring | All HealthSpring Medicare Advantage plans | See your member card | PPO |
These are the Suffolk plan cancellations affecting the most members. If your plan isn’t listed but you got a letter, match the plan ID on your member card, or schedule a quick call and we’ll check it for you.
Suffolk still has 18 standard Medicare Advantage plans for 2027, from carriers including Aetna, Anthem, EmblemHealth, Healthfirst, Humana, VNS and Wellcare.
A real Suffolk story
One of my clients, a couple in Northport, has been with me for 12 years. In that time, they’ve had to change plans five times because their plan kept going away. This year, their Humana Choice PPO was discontinued. No other plan in the area includes all of their doctors, and a Medicare Supplement isn’t in their budget. So we found them a plan that saves them money on their prescriptions, and we’re helping them find a couple of new doctors they’ll feel good about.
Sometimes there’s no perfect answer. But there’s always a best choice, and you shouldn’t have to find it alone.
Paul’s Honest Take for Suffolk PPO members: If your PPO is ending, don’t assume you need another PPO. Many of today’s HMOs don’t require referrals, and PPOs often charge 30% to 40% when you go out of network anyway. Start with your doctors, your prescriptions and your budget. The plan type comes after.
Your rights: how much time you have, and what you can choose
When your plan ends, Medicare gives you extra protections. Here’s what you’re entitled to.
Your key dates
Key dates if your plan is ending · Nov 2026 to Mar 2027
If you can, choose by December 7. Think of the Special Enrollment Period as your backup, not your plan.
Right #1: A Special Enrollment Period
Because your plan is ending through no fault of your own, you get extra time beyond Open Enrollment, through February 28, 2027, to choose a new Medicare Advantage plan or a stand-alone Part D drug plan. But don’t wait if you don’t have to. If you choose after December, you may have a gap with no drug coverage and none of your plan’s extras.
Right #2: Guaranteed access to a Medicare Supplement (Medigap)
If you’d rather leave Medicare Advantage and switch to Original Medicare with a Medigap plan:
- Federal law guarantees you can buy certain Medigap plans, with no health questions, when your plan ends. Apply up to 60 days before your plan ends and no later than 63 days after.
- In New York, you have even more protection. You can apply for any Medigap plan, from any company, any time of year, and you can’t be turned down or charged more because of your health.
If you go this route, you’ll also need a stand-alone Part D drug plan, and your special enrollment period lets you join one.
Right #3: The right to compare every option
You’re not stuck with the same insurance company. You can choose any Medicare Advantage plan offered in your county, from any carrier. You can also go back to Original Medicare.
What happens if you do nothing?
If you don’t choose a new plan, on January 1, 2027 you’ll automatically be moved to Original Medicare. That means:
- No drug coverage until you join a Part D plan. Going without it for too long can also trigger a lifelong late-enrollment penalty.
- No yearly out-of-pocket limit. Original Medicare alone has no cap on what you could pay.
- No dental, vision, hearing or other extras from your old plan.
Your doctors will still be paid by Medicare. But without a new plan, you’ll pay 20% of most costs with no limit.
One thing to check: Some letters say you’ll be moved automatically to a different plan from the same company. That’s not the same as your plan ending. You’ll still have coverage, but the new plan may have different doctors, drugs and costs. Review it just as carefully.
“I never got a letter!” and other mail mix-ups
This past week alone, I’ve talked with several Long Islanders who swear they never received a letter saying their plan was ending. Others got the letter, and then, the very same day, a colorful postcard from the same insurance company advertising other plans. Understandably, they had no idea what was real.
You’re not alone if this happened to you. In a 2025 survey of more than 1,500 people with Medicare, 24% said they don’t remember ever getting their Annual Notice of Change, according to eHealth, as reported by AJMC.
If you never got a letter
Plans are required to mail a non-renewal notice in early fall. But letters get lost, go to an old address, get mistaken for junk mail, or get opened by a spouse. Here’s how to check your plan’s status today:
- Call the member services number on the back of your card and ask, “Is my plan continuing in 2027?”
- Match your plan ID (on your card) to the Nassau and Suffolk lists above.
- Search for your plan on Medicare.gov’s Plan Finder for 2027. If you can’t find it, it may be ending.
- Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), any time, day or night.
- Or call me. I can check your plan’s status in a few minutes.
Missing the letter doesn’t take away your rights. If your plan is ending, you still have the same deadlines and the same Special Enrollment Period through February 28, 2027.
How to tell your mail apart
What you got | What it really is | What to do |
A letter saying your plan won’t continue in 2027 | Your official non-renewal notice. This one matters. | Keep it. Choose a new plan by December 7 if you can. |
An Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) | A summary of how your continuing plan changes next year | Read it. Check your doctors, drugs and costs. |
A letter saying you’ll be “moved” to a different plan | Your company is automatically switching you to another plan it offers | Review the new plan carefully. You don’t have to accept it. |
A glossy postcard or brochure about “new plans” | An advertisement. It doesn’t change your coverage. | Treat it as information only. Never enroll just because of an ad. |
A phone call saying “Medicare” is calling about your plan | Usually a sales call, not Medicare | Medicare won’t call you to sell a plan. Hang up and call a trusted source. |
Paul’s Honest Take: It isn’t fair that people get a cancellation letter and an ad from the same company on the same day. It’s confusing by design. So here’s my rule: nothing changes your coverage except an enrollment you choose yourself. A postcard can’t enroll you, and neither can a phone call you didn’t agree to. When in doubt, call me or 1-800-MEDICARE before you sign anything.
How to prepare: your simple checklist
You don’t need to figure this out in one sitting. Gather these things first, and choosing a new plan gets much easier.
- ☐ Find your letter. It’s called a non-renewal notice. Keep it, and note your plan ID.
- ☐ List every doctor you see, including specialists, and write down your hospital.
- ☐ List every prescription: the exact name, strength and how often you take it. The easy way is to take a photo of each pill bottle label.
- ☐ Write down your pharmacy, or two if you use more than one.
- ☐ Think about what you’ll need next year. A planned surgery? A new specialist? Physical therapy?
- ☐ Decide what matters most besides doctors and drugs. Is it a $0 premium? A low yearly out-of-pocket limit? Dental, vision or hearing?
- ☐ Use up your current extras before December 31: over-the-counter allowance, flex card, dental benefits.
- ☐ Compare plans, with help or on Medicare.gov’s Plan Finder. Put your doctors and prescriptions first.
- ☐ Call your doctors’ offices and ask, “Are you in-network for [plan name] in 2027?” Online directories aren’t always up to date.
- ☐ Enroll by December 7 if you can, so you have no gap.
What to look at, in order
- Your doctors and hospital are in the network.
- Your prescriptions are covered and affordable at your pharmacy.
- The copays you’ll actually use are affordable: primary care, specialists, hospital stays.
- The yearly out-of-pocket limit is a number you could handle in a bad year.
- Then look at plan type (HMO or PPO) and extras like dental, vision and hearing.
Paul’s Honest Take: Be careful with big dental allowances. Some plans offer $2,000 or $3,000 in dental coverage, but have very few dentists in their network. If dental matters to you, call your dentist and ask whether they take the plan before you enroll.
Have your list ready? I’ll check every plan for you. Bring your doctors, prescriptions and pharmacy, and we’ll compare every plan in your county together, side by side. Book your free plan review
Don’t worry: you still have plenty of options
Even with these plans ending, Long Island still has dozens of plans to choose from.
2027 plans available | Nassau County | Suffolk County |
Standard Medicare Advantage plans | 28 | 18 |
PPO plans | 10 | 4 (all Aetna) |
HMO-POS plans | 4 | 5 |
$0-premium plans | 15 | 7 |
Chronic-condition special needs plans (C-SNP) | 4 | 1 |
Dual-eligible plans, for people with Medicare and Medicaid (D-SNP) | 25 | 15 |
Plans for people in nursing homes or needing that level of care (I-SNP) | 6 | 5 |
Carriers offering Medicare Advantage in both counties: Aetna, Anthem, EmblemHealth, Healthfirst, Humana, VNS and Wellcare. Nassau only: Devoted Health (new for 2027) and VillageCareMAX. UnitedHealthcare offers only special needs plans on Long Island for 2027.
You can also choose a Medicare Supplement
If you’re tired of your plan changing every year, a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) may be worth a look:
- No networks. See any doctor or hospital in the country that takes Medicare.
- Your plan won’t be discontinued the way Medicare Advantage plans can be.
- In New York, you can apply any time, with no health questions.
- The trade-off is cost. Medigap premiums in downstate New York are much higher than most Medicare Advantage plans. High-Deductible Plan G often keeps the cost down. You’ll also need a stand-alone Part D drug plan. New York has 9 to choose from for 2027, starting at $37.30 a month.
There’s no single right answer. The best plan is the one that keeps your doctors, covers your prescriptions and fits your budget.
If you have both Medicare and Medicaid
If you have Medicaid, or you get help paying your Medicare costs through Extra Help or New York’s Medicare Savings Program, you have some extra options and protections:
- Plans built just for you. Long Island has 25 dual-eligible special needs plans (D-SNPs) in Nassau and 15 in Suffolk for 2027. These plans are designed to work alongside Medicaid and often include extra benefits.
- More chances to change. People with Medicaid or Extra Help can generally change their coverage more often during the year, not just during Open Enrollment.
- Some of these plans changed, too. A few special needs plans were merged or ended for 2027. If you got a letter, read it carefully, and ask for help if anything is unclear.
- Help with drug costs. Extra Help and New York’s EPIC program can lower what you pay for prescriptions. Many people qualify without realizing it.
The rules for dual-eligible plans are more complicated, so this is a good time to get one-on-one help.
Frequently asked questions
My plan is ending. Am I losing my Medicare? No. You keep Medicare no matter what. Only your Medicare Advantage plan is ending. You just need to choose how you’ll get your coverage in 2027.
How do I know if my plan is ending? Your plan was required to mail you a non-renewal letter this fall. You can also match the plan ID on your member card to the lists above, or call the number on the back of your card.
Can I stay with the same insurance company? Often, yes. Most of these carriers still offer other plans on Long Island. Just make sure the new plan includes your doctors and drugs, since networks and drug lists can differ from plan to plan within the same company.
I chose a new plan, but now I’ve changed my mind. Can I switch again? Yes. During Open Enrollment, the last plan you choose by December 7 is the one that counts. And from January 1 to March 31, anyone in a Medicare Advantage plan can make one more change.
Will my doctors take my new plan? Check the plan’s provider directory, then call your doctor’s office to confirm. Directories aren’t always current, so the phone call is the step that really matters.
What happens to my unused over-the-counter or flex card money? It generally expires on December 31, 2026 and doesn’t carry over to a new plan. Use it before then.
My PPO is ending. Do I have to take an HMO? Not necessarily. In Nassau, there are still 10 PPO plans. In Suffolk, Aetna is the only carrier with PPO plans. Many HMOs today don’t require referrals, so compare them on your doctors and costs before ruling them out.
Is there a cost to get help? No. My help is always free. You can also call New York’s HIICAP counseling program at 1-800-701-0501.
We’re here to help, every step of the way
If your plan is ending, you don’t have to sort through this alone. I’ve helped more than 5,000 people with Medicare over 18 years, and I’ve lived on Long Island for 55. Here’s how we can help:
- Answer your questions about your letter and your options, in plain English
- Check every plan in your county against your doctors, prescriptions and pharmacy
- Compare Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement options side by side, honestly
- Help you enroll in your new plan and make sure it starts on time
- Stay with you after enrollment if questions or problems come up
Reach out whichever way is easiest
- Schedule a free review or a quick call on my personal calendar, whichever you need: Pick a time with Paul
- Call or text me directly: 631-358-5793. I answer my own phone.
- Email: medicare@paulbinsurance.com
- Browse my free Medicare guides: See the guides
- Get my free weekly newsletter, read by more than 3,000 neighbors, with no sales pitch: Sign up here
There’s never any cost and never any pressure. My job is to help you find the right fit, not to sell you a plan.
Paul Barrett, CMIP, is the founder of The Modern Medicare Agency in Melville, NY. He’s an independent, Medicare-only broker with 18+ years of experience, the author of Medicare Mastery Unlocked, and host of the Wise Guys Retirement Talk podcast. He was recently quoted in Newsday on Medicare Advantage plan changes on Long Island.
We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 9 organizations which offer 24 products in Nassau County and 16 products in Suffolk County. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048), or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options. Plan information is current as of November 6, 2026 and may change. Always confirm your plan’s status using the plan ID on your member card.
Sources




