· @Paul
The quick answer
- Is my plan ending? Eight Staten Island Medicare Advantage plans end on December 31, 2026. The list is below. Check the plan ID on your insurance card, not just the name.
- What’s my deadline? Pick a new plan by December 7 so it starts January 1. If your plan is ending, you have extra time, until February 28, 2027.
- Who can help for free? Call me at 631-358-5793, or call HIICAP’s Staten Island office at 718-981-6226.
Last updated: November 10, 2026
If you live on Staten Island and got a letter saying your Medicare Advantage plan is ending, take a breath. You have not lost your Medicare. You still have time, and you still have good choices.
For 2027, eight Medicare Advantage plans sold in Richmond County are not coming back, and three more are being folded into other plans. Most of them are plans for people who have both Medicare and Medicaid. A few are regular plans that many Staten Islanders have used for years. All told, Medicare.gov shows 18 standard Medicare Advantage plans for Staten Island in 2027 (with or without drug coverage, not counting special needs plans), down from 25 in 2026. That’s 7 fewer choices, or about 1 in 4 gone in a single year.
Below, I’ll walk you through exactly which plans are ending, what your deadlines are, and what I’d do if I were in your shoes. No sales pitch. Just the plain facts, like we’re sitting at your kitchen table.
Which Staten Island plans are ending in 2027?
These eight plans will not be offered in 2027. If you are in one of them, your coverage ends on December 31, 2026, and you need to pick a new plan.
Regular Medicare Advantage plans ending
Plan | Plan ID | Type | 2026 star rating |
|---|---|---|---|
Aetna Medicare Enhanced | H3312-082 | HMO | 3 stars |
Elderplan Extra Help | H3347-009 | HMO-POS | 3.5 stars |
Elderplan Flex | H3347-016 | HMO-POS | 3.5 stars |
HealthSpring True Choice | H7849-150 | PPO | 3 stars |
Plans for people with Medicare and Medicaid (D-SNPs) ending
Plan | Plan ID | Type | 2026 star rating |
|---|---|---|---|
Aetna Medicare Partial Dual Care | H3312-090 | HMO D-SNP | 3 stars |
EmblemHealth VIP Dual | H5991-012 | HMO D-SNP | 3 stars |
EmblemHealth VIP Dual Enhanced | H5991-013 | HMO D-SNP | 3 stars |
Wellcare Fidelis Dual Liberty Sync | H5599-013 | HMO D-SNP | 3 stars |
A word of caution on that last one. For 2027, Wellcare is giving the same name, “Fidelis Dual Liberty Sync,” to a different plan (H5599-015, which used to be called Wellcare Dual Access). So the plan name may look familiar next year, but if your plan ID is H5599-013, your plan is ending. Always check the plan ID on your card, not just the name.
If you have the HealthSpring True Choice PPO, pay special attention. PPO members usually picked that plan to see doctors across the five boroughs and New Jersey without referrals, so you’ll want a replacement that keeps that freedom.
Plans being merged into another plan
Three dual-eligible plans are not disappearing. Instead, your insurance company is moving you into a sister plan automatically. You don’t have to do anything to stay covered, but the costs change, so it’s worth a look.
Your 2026 plan | Moving into (2027) | What changes |
|---|---|---|
Anthem HealthPlus Full Dual Advantage LTSS (H8432-041) | Anthem HealthPlus Full Dual Advantage LTSS 2 | Listed premium goes from $0 to $40.50 a month; drug deductible $615 to $700; out-of-pocket max $9,250 to $9,850; star rating 3.5 to 5 |
Humana Gold Plus SNP-DE (H3533-002) | Humana Gold Plus SNP-DE (H3533-036) | $0 premium stays; drug deductible $615 to $700; out-of-pocket max $9,250 to $9,850 |
Humana Gold Plus SNP-DE (H3533-034) | Humana Gold Plus SNP-DE (H3533-036) | $0 premium stays; drug deductible $615 to $700; out-of-pocket max $9,250 to $9,850 |
If you have full Medicaid, Medicaid usually picks up most of these costs. And if you get Extra Help with your drugs, it may cover some or all of that Anthem premium. Still, read the Annual Notice of Change your plan mailed you, and check that your doctors and pharmacy are in the new plan’s network.
“Why do we have to change plans every year?”
I hear this a lot from my Staten Island clients lately, and I understand the frustration. Some of them have changed plans two or three years in a row, and they feel like they did something wrong. You didn’t.
Staten Island has the same problem we see out in Suffolk County. A big-name insurance company comes in with a really good plan. Lots of people sign up. Then a year or two later, the company decides the plan isn’t working for them, and it leaves. Then the next one comes in, and the same thing happens. We’ve watched it happen with Blue Cross, UnitedHealthcare, Humana and Aetna.
Here’s the mindset that I think helps the most: a Medicare Advantage plan is something you use, not something you own. Every plan is a one-year contract between the insurance company and Medicare. Nobody promises it will be there next year.
So if Blue Cross works best for you this year, you use Blue Cross. If Aetna works best next year, you use Aetna. Your Medicare itself never goes anywhere. Only the plan on top of it changes. Please don’t take it personally when a plan closes. It’s a business decision by the insurance company, and it has nothing to do with you.
And if changing every year is just too much stress, that’s worth saying out loud. Original Medicare with a Medigap supplement doesn’t get pulled out from under you this way, and in New York you can apply for one any time of year. It costs more each month, but for some people the peace of mind is worth it. We can talk through both.
What happens if you do nothing?
If your plan is ending and you don’t choose a new one, you won’t be left with zero coverage. On January 1, 2027, you’ll go back to Original Medicare (Part A and Part B).
Here’s the catch: Original Medicare does not include prescription drug coverage. If you take any medications, that gap can get expensive fast. And if you go too long without drug coverage, Medicare can add a late penalty to your drug premium for as long as you have it.
So please don’t let this one slide. A short phone call now can save you a big headache in January.
Your deadlines
You actually have two windows, and that’s good news.
Window | Dates | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
Annual Enrollment Period | October 15 to December 7, 2026 | Pick a new plan now, and it starts January 1, 2027. No gap. |
Special Enrollment Period (only if your plan is ending) | December 8, 2026 to February 28, 2027 | Extra time to choose. Your new plan starts the first of the month after you sign up. |
My advice: use the first window if you can. If you wait until January, you could spend a few weeks on Original Medicare with no drug plan.
A New York bonus most people don’t know about. In New York, you can buy a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan any time of year, and the company can’t turn you down or charge you more because of your health. So if you’ve been thinking about leaving Medicare Advantage for Original Medicare plus a supplement, New York makes that door easier to walk through than most states.
Why there’s no simple “swap” for your old plan
People ask me all the time, “My plan is gone, so which one is the same?” I wish it were that easy. Just because you had a Humana HMO doesn’t mean an Aetna HMO is your match. The right plan for you depends on four things:
- Your doctors. Your primary doctor and every specialist you see.
- Your hospital. Where you’d want to go if something serious happened.
- Your prescriptions. Every drug, every dose, and the pharmacy you use.
- Your budget. What you can afford every month, and what you could handle if you had a bad year.
Two neighbors on the same street can lose the same plan and end up in two completely different plans. That’s normal, and it’s exactly why I go through those four things with every client before we look at a single plan.
Staten Island hospitals: start your search here
On Staten Island, the hospital question usually comes first. The island has two main hospital systems, and most local doctors are tied to one or the other.
Hospital | Where | Connected to | Good to know |
|---|---|---|---|
475 Seaview Ave, 10305 | Northwell Health | Level I trauma center; designated heart attack (STEMI) center | |
375 Seguine Ave, 10309 | Northwell Health | South Shore campus; state-certified stroke center | |
West Brighton, North Shore | Independent, with Mount Sinai and SUNY Downstate affiliations | About 440 beds; Level I adult trauma center |
What this means for you: before you pick any plan, check that your hospital is in its network, not just your doctor. If you see a Northwell doctor, make sure SIUH is covered. If your doctors are on the North Shore and send patients to RUMC, check RUMC.
One thing to keep an eye on. RUMC’s new president told NY1 in August 2026 that the hospital is talking with larger systems about a possible merger. He named NYU Langone, Mount Sinai and Northwell as possible partners, and said he hoped to have one within the next couple of years. Nothing changes for patients today, but a merger could change which plans include RUMC down the road. That’s one more reason to review your plan every fall.
If you get care off the island
A lot of Staten Islanders see specialists in Manhattan or Brooklyn, or cross the bridges into New Jersey. That’s where plan type really matters.
- HMO plans usually cover only doctors and hospitals in their network. A Manhattan specialist may be covered; a New Jersey hospital often isn’t, except in an emergency.
- PPO plans let you go out of network, usually for a higher cost, and you don’t need referrals.
If you were in the HealthSpring PPO because you see doctors in New Jersey or across the city, tell your agent that first. It narrows your choices fast.
Staten Island by the numbers
- 25 to 18: the number of standard Medicare Advantage plans (with or without drug coverage, not counting special needs plans) on Medicare.gov for Staten Island, from 2026 to 2027.
- Staten Island’s 65-and-over population grew 34% from 2011 to 2021, the fastest of any borough. By 2021, about 17% of residents were 65 or older. (Center for an Urban Future, via Spotlight on Poverty)
- About 70% of older adults who rent on Staten Island are rent-burdened, the highest share in the city. (NY State Comptroller)
That second number is why budget belongs on your list. A $0-premium plan with a high out-of-pocket maximum can still hurt in a bad year.
Free local help on Staten Island
You don’t have to figure this out alone, and you don’t have to pay anyone.
- HIICAP (free Medicare counseling): Community Agency for Senior Citizens, 120 Stuyvesant Place, Suite 409, Staten Island, NY 10301. Call 718-981-6226 for an appointment, Monday to Friday. (NYC Aging HIICAP sites)
- NYC Aging Connect: 212-AGING-NYC (212-244-6469), and ask for HIICAP.
- Medicare: 1-800-MEDICARE or Medicare.gov.
- A local independent agent like me, at no cost to you.
What to do now, step by step
- Find your letter. Plans had to mail a non-renewal notice by early October. It looks like plain insurance mail, so check the pile on the counter.
- Check the plan ID on your card. It starts with a letter and four numbers, like H3347-016. Compare it to the lists above.
- Write down your doctors. Include your primary doctor, your specialists, and the hospital you’d want to go to, whether that’s Staten Island University Hospital, Richmond University Medical Center, or a Manhattan hospital.
- Grab your pill bottles. Write down every medication and the dose. Drug coverage is where plans differ the most.
- Compare plans side by side. Use the Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov, call 1-800-MEDICARE, or sit down with a local licensed agent who can check your doctors and drugs for you at no cost.
- Enroll by December 7 so your new plan starts January 1, with no gap.
New plans on Staten Island for 2027
There’s some good news too. Several new plans are coming to Staten Island for 2027, including new options from Aetna, Anthem, AARP/UnitedHealthcare and Devoted Health.
Plan | Type | Monthly premium | Drug coverage |
|---|---|---|---|
Aetna Medicare Eagle Giveback | PPO | $0 | No |
Aetna Medicare Elite | HMO | $109 | Yes |
AARP Medicare Advantage Patriot No Rx NY-MA3 | HMO-POS | $0 | No |
Anthem Veteran 2 | HMO-POS | $0 | No |
Devoted Choice 009 NY | PPO | $0 | Yes |
Devoted Choice Giveback 010 NY | PPO | $0 | Yes |
Devoted Choice Giveback Extras 032 NY | PPO | $0 | Yes |
Aetna Medicare Chronic Care Total | HMO C-SNP (chronic conditions) | $0 | Yes |
Devoted C-SNP Choice Enhanced 020, Plus 014 and Giveback Extras 026 NY | PPO C-SNP (chronic conditions) | $0 | Yes |
Aetna Medicare FIDE | HMO D-SNP (Medicare + Medicaid) | $40.50 | Yes |
A few honest notes on these:
- No-drug plans are mostly for veterans. Plans without drug coverage usually make sense only if you get your medications through the VA or TRICARE.
- “Giveback” plans put part of your Part B premium back into your Social Security check. That’s nice, but it should never be the reason you pick a plan.
- Some new plans, like Devoted’s, have no star rating yet. That doesn’t mean they’re bad. It just means there’s no track record to look at.
Paul’s Honest Take
I’ve been helping people with Medicare for over 18 years, and I can tell you the folks who get hit hardest by plan closings aren’t the ones who love shopping every fall. It’s the ones who picked a good plan years ago and hoped they’d never have to think about it again. If that’s you, I get it.
Here’s what I’d tell you at the kitchen table. Don’t grab the first plan that shows up in a commercial, and don’t pick one because of a gym card or a grocery allowance. Those extras come and go. What matters is whether your doctors, your hospital and your medications are covered, and what you’ll pay when you actually get sick.
And please don’t wait until the last week. December 7 sneaks up on everybody.
Common questions
My plan is ending. Will I lose my Medicare? No. Your Medicare Part A and Part B stay with you. Only your Medicare Advantage plan is ending.
I got a letter, but my plan’s name is on the 2027 list. Am I OK? Maybe not. Check the plan ID, not just the name. Wellcare, for example, is reusing the “Fidelis Dual Liberty Sync” name on a different plan for 2027.
My plan is being merged. Do I have to do anything? No, you’ll be moved over automatically. But your costs may change, so read your Annual Notice of Change and make sure your doctors are still in network.
Can I switch to a Medigap plan instead? Yes. In New York, Medigap plans are available all year, and you can’t be turned down or charged more for your health. You’d also want a separate Part D drug plan.
What if I have Medicare and Medicaid? Most of the plans ending on Staten Island are for people with both. You still need to choose a new plan, and your Medicaid benefits stay in place. A free local agent or New York’s HIICAP counselors can help you compare dual plans.
Does it cost anything to talk to an agent? No. Licensed agents are paid by the insurance companies, not by you. The plan costs the same whether you enroll on your own or with help.
Need a hand? No pressure, just answers.
If your plan is ending, or you just want a second set of eyes on your options, I’m happy to help. I’m an independent broker, so I’m not tied to one insurance company, and I’ll never rush you.
Pick whatever is easiest for you:
- Call me directly: 631-358-5793. I answer my own phone.
- Book a time to talk: Schedule a quick chat
- Email me: medicare@paulbinsurance.com
- Read first, talk later: Free Medicare guides
About Paul Barrett, CMIP
Paul is the founder of The Modern Medicare Agency, a small, family-owned independent agency. He has helped Medicare clients for more than 18 years and has served over 5,000 people, including clients on Staten Island, across the other boroughs and on Long Island. He’s AHIP-certified, the author of Medicare Mastery Unlocked, and the host of the Wise Guys Retirement Talk podcast. Paul has more than 100 five-star Google reviews, still answers his own phone, and never charges for his help. Licensed independent Medicare broker, NPN 5316441.
We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 7 organizations which offer 17 products in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.
Plan information comes from CMS 2027 plan data and may change. Always confirm details in your plan’s Evidence of Coverage or on Medicare.gov.
Sources
- Plan lists, plan counts and costs: CMS 2027 plan data and the Medicare Plan Finder for Richmond County
- Enrollment periods and plan non-renewal rights: Medicare.gov
- Staten Island University Hospital: Ocean Breeze (North) campus and Prince’s Bay (South) campus, Northwell Health
- Richmond University Medical Center: NY1, August 6, 2026 and Mount Sinai, June 2, 2022
- Staten Island senior population: Center for an Urban Future, via Spotlight on Poverty
- Older renters’ housing costs: New York State Comptroller, January 2025
- Free counseling sites: NYC Aging HIICAP locations




