Your Right to Switch Medigap Plans: A State-by-State Guide for Medicare Supplement Owners
· @Paul
If you have a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan, here’s something most people never hear: the fall Open Enrollment period has nothing to do with your Medigap plan. You don’t have to wait for October 15 to December 7 to change it, and in almost every state, that window doesn’t give you any special right to switch. (Rhode Island is the one exception.) What decides whether you can switch is the state you live in.
Every fall, I talk to Medigap owners who are nervous, confused, or paying far more than they need to. Some think they missed their chance. Some think switching is risky. And some, especially people who’ve been sick, think they should never touch a plan that’s “working.” This guide explains your real rights, in plain English.
The quick answer
Your question | The answer |
|---|---|
Does fall Open Enrollment let me switch Medigap plans? | No. Open Enrollment is for Medicare Advantage and Part D drug plans. |
Can I switch Medigap plans any time? | You can apply any time. Whether the company can ask health questions depends on your state. |
Which states let you switch all year with no health questions? | New York and Connecticut, plus a few others with special rules (see the state guide below). |
What’s a “birthday rule”? | A yearly window, around your birthday, when you can switch without health questions. A growing number of states have one. |
Is Plan G from one company the same as Plan G from another? | Yes. Benefits are standardized by federal law. Only the price and the company’s service differ. |
What should Medigap owners do during Open Enrollment? | Review your Part D drug plan. That’s the part of your coverage this window is for. |
Why switching can save you real money
Plan G is Plan G, no matter which company sells it
This is the most important fact in this whole guide. Medigap plans are standardized by federal law. A Plan G from one insurance company covers exactly the same things as a Plan G from any other company. The same goes for Plan N, Plan F and every other letter. (Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin use their own standardized plans, but the same idea applies.)
That means when you switch companies but keep the same plan letter, your benefits don’t change at all. You can still see any doctor in the country who takes Medicare. No networks, no referrals. The only things that change are:
- The price you pay
- The company’s customer service and how they handle rate increases over time
So if two companies charge different prices for the exact same Plan G, the cheaper one is usually the smarter choice.
Medigap premiums keep climbing
According to KFF, the average Medigap premium was $244 a month in 2025, up 7% in one year and 20% since 2020. New York had the highest average in the country, at $306 a month.
Plan | Share of Medigap owners | Average monthly premium (2025) | Increase since 2020 |
|---|---|---|---|
Plan G | 46% (most popular) | $194 (New York: $257) | 38% |
Plan F | About 30% | $325 | 37% |
Plan N | 10% | Not reported | Not reported |
Why Plan F is getting so expensive
Plan F hasn’t been sold to anyone new to Medicare since January 1, 2020. No new, healthier 65-year-olds are joining it, so the group keeps getting older and filing more claims. That pushes premiums up year after year. If you’re still on Plan F, you’re paying for a plan whose price has nowhere to go but up. Learn more about why Medicare Supplement premiums keep going up, and what you can do about it.
A real story: the couple who “did what all their friends did”
Recently I helped a husband and wife who had been on Plan F for nine years. They were loyal to it. Most of their friends had the same coverage, so it felt like the smart, safe choice.
But when we looked back together, they had barely used their coverage at all in those nine years. They were paying top dollar every month for protection they rarely needed, and the premium kept going up.
Because they became eligible for Medicare before 2020, they could move to High-Deductible Plan F. It has the same benefits as Plan F once the deductible is met, for a much lower premium. Together, they’re now saving a little over $2,400 a year. Their reaction? They couldn’t believe they hadn’t made the switch sooner.
High-Deductible Plan F is only available to people who were eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020. Everyone else can consider High-Deductible Plan G, which works the same way.
The math: Plan G vs. High-Deductible Plan G in downstate New York
Here’s the comparison I walk every client through. In downstate New York (Long Island and New York City), Plan G typically costs $400 a month or more for 2027. High-Deductible Plan G typically costs $100 a month or less. Both cover exactly the same things. The only difference is who pays first.
| Plan G | High-Deductible Plan G |
|---|---|---|
Typical monthly premium (downstate NY, 2027) | $400 | $100 |
Premiums for the year | $4,800 | $1,200 |
Most you’d pay out of pocket for covered care | $283 (the Part B deductible) | $3,050 (the plan’s deductible) |
If you barely use it all year | About $4,800 | About $1,200 |
Worst possible year (premiums + full deductible) | $5,083 | $4,250 |
High-Deductible Plan G wins either way. In a healthy year, you’d save about $3,600. In the worst year you could possibly have, you’d still save about $833.
Why? The premium savings ($3,600 a year) are bigger than the most extra you could ever pay out of pocket (about $2,767 more). So no matter how much care you use, High-Deductible Plan G costs less.
Paul’s Honest Take: At these prices, I can’t find a way to justify regular Plan G over High-Deductible Plan G in downstate New York. And remember, in New York you can switch any time, with no health questions. If your situation ever changes, you’re not locked in. For the full picture, read my complete guide to High-Deductible Plan G.
Prices vary by ZIP code and company. The Part B deductible shown is the 2026 amount; the 2027 amount hasn’t been announced yet. Ask for quotes in your ZIP code to run your own numbers.
Paul’s Honest Take: Every year I see people paying hundreds of dollars more than they need to for the exact same coverage, simply because they never knew they could switch. If you live in a state that protects you, you’re allowed to shop. And in many cases, you should.
Your right to switch depends on your state
In most of the country, if you want to change Medigap plans after your first six months on Medicare, the insurance company can ask about your health. It can say no or charge you more. But a growing number of states protect you. Here’s where your state stands, based on KFF’s October 2026 review of state rules.
Group 1: Switch any time, with no health questions
State | Your right |
|---|---|
New York | Switch to any Medigap plan, from any company, any time of year. No health questions. |
Connecticut | Same as New York: any plan, any company, any time. No health questions. |
Massachusetts | By law there’s a yearly window (February 1 to March 31), but in practice every insurer accepts applications year-round. Massachusetts uses its own plan names (like Core and Supplement 1A). |
In these states, insurers also must use community rating. Everyone in the same area pays the same price for the same plan, no matter their age or health.
Group 2: Switch any time to a plan with equal or fewer benefits
State | Your right |
|---|---|
Maine | Switch any time to a plan with the same or fewer benefits, as long as you haven’t had a gap in coverage of 90 days or more. |
Washington | Same as Maine. Exception: Plan A owners can only switch to another Plan A. |
Group 3: A yearly switching window
State | Your right |
|---|---|
Missouri | Switch to an equivalent plan from a different company within 30 days before or after your policy’s anniversary date each year. |
Rhode Island | Switch to any Medigap plan from any company during Medicare’s fall Open Enrollment period. This is the one state where fall Open Enrollment does matter for Medigap. |
Group 4: The “birthday rule” states
In these 16 states, you get a yearly window around your birthday to switch without health questions. You can usually move to a plan with the same or fewer benefits (for example, Plan G to Plan G, or Plan G to Plan N). Details are from MedicareResources.org and KFF.
State | Your window | What you can switch to |
|---|---|---|
California | 60 days, starting the first day of your birth month | Same or fewer benefits, any company |
Delaware | Starts 30 days before your birthday (new in 2026) | Same or fewer benefits |
Idaho | 63 days | Same or fewer benefits, any company |
Illinois | 45 days (ages 65 to 75 only) | Same or fewer benefits, your current company or its affiliate |
Indiana | Around your birthday (new in 2026) | The same plan letter, any company |
Kentucky | 60 days | The same plan letter |
Louisiana | 63 days | Same or fewer benefits, your current company or its affiliate |
Maryland | 30 days | Same or fewer benefits |
Nevada | 60 days, starting the first day of your birth month | Same or fewer benefits, any company |
New Mexico | Around your birthday (starts January 2027) | Same or fewer benefits |
Oklahoma | 60 days | Same or fewer benefits (no coverage gap over 90 days) |
Oregon | 30 days, starting the first day of your birth month | Same or fewer benefits, any company |
Utah | 60 days | Same or fewer benefits, your current company only |
Virginia | Around your birthday (new in 2025) | The same plan letter, any company |
West Virginia | 60 days (must have had your plan 24+ months) | Same or fewer benefits, usually your current company or its affiliate |
Wyoming | 63 days after your birthday | Same or fewer benefits, any company |
Birthday rules are new in many states and details can change. Always confirm your exact window with your state’s free SHIP counseling program before you cancel anything.
A real story: “I wish I could get a rate like that”
I was helping a client in Los Angeles enroll his wife, who is younger and was new to Medicare. While we were on the phone, he said, “I wish I could switch and get a rate like that.”
It turned out his birthday was in November, which put him right inside California’s birthday-rule window. We moved his Plan G from one company to another, with no health questions. His coverage stayed exactly the same, and his premium dropped by $39 a month. That’s $468 a year, every year, for doing nothing more than asking a question.
If you live in a birthday-rule state, put a reminder on your calendar a month before your birthday every year. It’s the easiest annual raise you’ll ever give yourself.
Everyone else: you can still apply
If your state isn’t listed, you can still apply to switch at any time. The company will ask health questions. If you’re in reasonably good health, you may well be approved, sometimes at a much lower price. Just never cancel your current plan until your new one is approved in writing.
“I was sick, so I’d better not change anything.” Here’s why that’s backwards.
This is the conversation I have most often with Medigap owners in New York. Someone has been through cancer treatment, heart surgery or a hard few years. Their plan paid for everything. So when I mention they could save money by switching, they get nervous:
“My plan has been so good to me. I don’t want to rock the boat.”
I completely understand that feeling. But in New York and Connecticut, that’s exactly the situation these protections were made for. Here’s why switching is safe:
- The new company can’t turn you down. Your health history doesn’t matter. Not your cancer, not your surgery, not your prescriptions.
- The new company can’t charge you more because you were sick. These states use community rating, so you pay the same price as your healthy neighbor.
- Your coverage is exactly the same. Plan G is Plan G. Your new plan covers the same things your old one did, the very same way.
- Your doctors don’t change. Medigap has no networks. Any doctor or hospital that takes Medicare takes your new plan.
- There’s no waiting period for pre-existing conditions when you switch under these protections.
Your old plan wasn’t “good to you” because it was special. It paid your bills because every Plan G is required to pay those same bills. The only real difference between your plan and another company’s version is the price.
Paul’s Honest Take: Loyalty to a Medigap company doesn’t pay. Prices for the exact same plan can vary widely from one company to the next, and the company that was cheapest when you signed up may not be today. If you live in a protected state, staying put out of fear may be costing you hundreds or even thousands of dollars a year, for coverage that’s identical.
One thing to check before you switch
If you’re on Plan F and you switch, you generally can’t get Plan F from a new company. It’s closed to most new buyers. Your choices would be Plan G or Plan N, which cover almost everything Plan F does. The main difference: you’d pay the small Part B deductible yourself ($283 in 2026). For most people, the premium savings more than make up for it. And if you became eligible for Medicare before 2020, some companies may still sell you Plan F. Ask.
Rights you have in every state
Even if your state has no special protections, federal law gives everyone “guaranteed issue” rights in certain situations. During these windows, a Medigap company can’t turn you down, charge you more because of your health, or make you wait for coverage of a pre-existing condition.
1. Your first six months on Medicare
Your Medigap Open Enrollment Period starts the month you’re 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. For six months, you can buy any Medigap plan sold in your state, with no health questions. This is a one-time window. It never comes back.
2. The Medicare Advantage “trial right”
This is a safety net for people trying Medicare Advantage for the first time. It works in two ways.
| If you joined Medicare Advantage right at 65 | If you dropped a Medigap plan to try Medicare Advantage |
|---|---|---|
Who it’s for | You picked a Medicare Advantage plan when you first became eligible for Medicare at 65. | You had a Medigap plan, then dropped it to join a Medicare Advantage plan for the first time ever. |
How long you have | Your first 12 months in the plan | Your first 12 months in the plan |
What you can buy | Any Medigap plan sold in your state, from any company | Your old Medigap plan back, if the same company still sells it. If not, a standard plan such as Plan A, B, D, G, K or L. |
The trial right is one-time only. Once you pass the 12-month mark, it’s gone, and your state’s normal rules apply.
3. Other situations that protect you
You also get guaranteed-issue rights when:
- Your Medicare Advantage plan stops serving your area or leaves Medicare, as many plans are doing for 2027
- You move out of your Medicare Advantage plan’s service area
- Your employer or union retiree coverage ends
- Your Medigap company goes out of business or ends your coverage through no fault of your own
- Your Medicare Advantage plan or Medigap company broke the rules or misled you
The timing rules that matter
- Apply within 63 days after your old coverage ends.
- You can apply up to 60 days before your Medicare Advantage plan ends, so there’s no gap.
- If your old plan included drug coverage, you’ll also get a special chance to join a stand-alone Part D plan, so you don’t face a late-enrollment penalty.
Sources: KFF and Indiana SHIP’s federal Medigap rights guide. If you became eligible for Medicare before 2020, Plans C and F may also be available to you.
What Medigap owners should do this Open Enrollment
Here’s my step-by-step checklist for anyone with a Medicare Supplement plan.
- Review your Part D drug plan. This is what fall Open Enrollment is really for, if you have Medigap. Your stand-alone drug plan can change its premium, deductible and drug list every year. For 2027, the yearly cap on drug costs is $2,400 and deductibles can be as high as $700. Compare plans by your total yearly cost, and make any change by December 7.
- Look at your latest Medigap rate notice. How much did your premium go up this year? How does it compare with what other companies charge for the same plan letter?
- Find your state in the guide above. Do you have year-round rights, a birthday window, or neither?
- Compare the same plan from other companies. Same letter, same benefits, different price. In a protected state, this is the easiest money you’ll ever save.
- Consider a plan with lower premiums. If your premium keeps climbing:
- Plan N has lower premiums. In exchange, you pay small copays at the doctor and emergency room. See my honest comparison of Plan G vs. Plan N.
- High-Deductible Plan G has much lower premiums. You pay a yearly deductible first ($3,050 in 2027), then it covers the same things as Plan G. In downstate New York at 2027 prices, it costs less than regular Plan G even in the worst possible year (see the math above).
- Never cancel your current plan first. Apply for the new plan, wait until it’s approved in writing, and set it to start the day after your old plan ends.
- Use your 30-day “free look.” When you buy a new Medigap policy, you get 30 days to decide whether to keep it. You’ll pay both premiums for that month, but you’re protected if something isn’t right.
- If you’re in Medicare Advantage and unhappy, check whether you still have your 12-month trial right. In New York and Connecticut, you can switch back to Medigap any time.
Paul’s Honest Take: I recommend High-Deductible Plan G to a lot of my clients, even though it pays me less, because it often saves them more. The right plan is the one that fits your budget and protects you in a bad year, not the one with the biggest commission.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to wait for Open Enrollment to change my Medigap plan? No. In most states, Open Enrollment (October 15 to December 7) has nothing to do with Medigap. You can apply to switch any time. Whether you’ll face health questions depends on your state.
I live in New York. Can a Medigap company turn me down because of my health? No. New York requires every Medigap company to accept you, any time of year, for any plan they sell. They also can’t charge you more because of your health or age.
If I switch companies, will I lose my doctors? No. Medigap has no networks. Any doctor or hospital in the country that accepts Medicare accepts every Medigap plan.
Is a cheaper Plan G “worse” than an expensive one? No. Plan G benefits are set by federal law and are identical at every company. A lower price doesn’t mean less coverage.
I was in the hospital last year. Should I keep my plan just to be safe? If you live in a protected state like New York or Connecticut, your health history doesn’t affect your right to switch or your price. Your new plan would cover you exactly the same way.
What’s the difference between a birthday rule and year-round rights? Year-round rights let you switch any day of the year. A birthday rule gives you a set window each year, usually 30 to 63 days around your birthday, and usually only to a plan with the same or fewer benefits.
Can I switch from Plan G to Plan N or High-Deductible Plan G? Yes. Both have fewer benefits than Plan G, so they’re allowed in most birthday-rule states, and in any state if you pass health questions. In New York and Connecticut, you can switch to any plan at any time.
Can I go back to Medigap if I try Medicare Advantage? If it’s your first time in Medicare Advantage, you generally have 12 months to switch back with guaranteed rights. In New York and Connecticut, you can return to Medigap any time.
The bottom line
- Fall Open Enrollment is for your drug plan, not your Medigap plan. Review your Part D plan by December 7.
- Your state decides your switching rights. In New York and Connecticut, you can switch any time, with no health questions. In 16 birthday-rule states, you get a yearly window.
- Every plan letter is standardized. Switching companies doesn’t change your benefits or your doctors. It only changes your price.
- Being sick is not a reason to stay put in a protected state. It’s the reason those protections exist.
Want someone to check your options?
There’s no pressure and no cost. Reach out whichever way is easiest:
- Schedule a free chat with me at a time that works for you: Book a time with Paul
- Browse my free Medicare guides: See the guides
- Get my free weekly newsletter, read by more than 3,000 neighbors, with no sales pitch: Sign up here
- Call or text me directly: 631-358-5793. I answer my own phone.
- Email: medicare@paulbinsurance.com
- Outside New York? Your state’s free SHIP counseling program can confirm your exact rights. Find yours at shiphelp.org.
Paul Barrett, CMIP, is the founder of The Modern Medicare Agency in Melville, NY. He’s an independent, Medicare-only broker with 18+ years of experience and more than 5,000 clients helped, the author of Medicare Mastery Unlocked, and host of the Wise Guys Retirement Talk podcast.
We do not offer every plan available in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048), or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options. State Medigap rules change often. Information is current as of November 3, 2026. Always confirm your rights with your state insurance department or SHIP before canceling any coverage.
Sources
- KFF: Medigap Guaranteed Issue Requirements, an Overview of Federal and State Rules (Oct 2026)
- KFF: Key Facts About Medigap Enrollment and Premiums (Oct 2026)
- MedicareResources.org: The Birthday Rule, a Gift to Medigap Enrollees (Jul 2026)
- Indiana SHIP: Your Medigap Rights




