Oct 25, 2026 · @Paul
Medicare on Long Island is its own animal
If your mailbox has been stuffed with Medicare flyers since September, you’re not alone. Every fall, Long Islanders get buried in TV ads, postcards and phone calls, most from national call centers that couldn’t find Patchogue on a map.
I’ve lived on Long Island for 55 years, and I’ve spent the last 18 helping my neighbors with Medicare. Here’s what I can tell you: Medicare works differently here than in Florida or Arizona. New York has its own rules for supplement plans. Our hospital systems shape which plans make sense. And the plans available in Nassau aren’t the same as the ones in Suffolk.
So let’s sit down at the kitchen table and walk through it together, in plain English. No pressure, no sales pitch. If you want the full picture with maps, hospitals and plan lists, my Long Island Medicare guide has it all in one place.
The short answer for 2027: Nassau County has 28 standard Medicare Advantage plans and Suffolk has 18. New York lets you buy a Medicare Supplement any time of year, at the same price regardless of age. Only 9 standalone drug plans are offered statewide, and drug costs are capped at $2,400 for the year. Your choice should start with your doctors and hospitals, not the premium. Open Enrollment runs October 15 to December 7.
Your two main roads
Every Long Islander on Medicare ends up choosing between two roads. Neither one is “right” for everyone. It depends on your doctors, your health, your budget and how much you like predictability.
Original Medicare + a Supplement (Medigap) | Medicare Advantage (Part C) | |
|---|---|---|
Monthly cost | Higher premium for the supplement | Often low or $0 premium |
Costs when you get care | Very little, often almost nothing | Copays as you go, up to a yearly cap |
Doctors and hospitals | Any provider in the country that takes Medicare | Usually a network; PPOs allow out-of-network at higher cost |
Drug coverage | Add a separate Part D plan | Usually built in |
Extras (dental, vision, hearing) | Not included | Often included |
Often a good fit for | People who want freedom and predictable costs | People who want lower premiums and are comfortable with a network |
One thing to know up front: a lot of people think the “free” plan on TV is the whole story. A $0 premium is real, but it isn’t the same as $0 cost. We’ll look at what really matters below.
2027 Medicare numbers at a glance
These are the federal limits that apply to every plan on Long Island in 2027. Keep this table handy when you compare.
2027 figure | Amount | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
Medicare Advantage in-network out-of-pocket limit | $9,850 | The most any Medicare Advantage plan can make you pay for in-network medical care in a year (up from $9,250 in 2026). Many plans set theirs lower. |
Medicare Advantage combined limit (PPO, in + out of network) | $14,800 | The cap when you use doctors outside the network on a PPO. |
Part D yearly drug cost cap | $2,400 | The most you’ll pay for covered prescriptions in a year (up from $2,100 in 2026). |
Maximum Part D deductible | $700 | Up from $615 in 2026. Many New York drug plans charge the full amount. |
Original Medicare out-of-pocket limit | None | Original Medicare alone has no cap. That’s why most people pair it with a supplement. |
Sources: CMS 2027 limits, summarized and AP coverage of 2027 Part D changes.
Why New York is different for Medigap
New York is one of the friendliest states in the country for Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans. Two rules make the difference.
Everyone in your ZIP code pays the same rate. New York uses “community rating.” A 66-year-old and an 80-year-old in the same Huntington ZIP code pay the same premium for the same plan. In most states, rates climb as you age.
You can apply any time of year. In most states, you get one easy shot at a supplement. Miss it, and you may face health questions and could be turned down. New York requires insurers to accept you year-round, with no health questions. Only one other state, Connecticut, does the same.
One catch to know about. If you haven’t had health coverage recently, some companies can make you wait a few months (2 to 6, depending on the company) before covering a pre-existing condition. If you’re coming straight from employer coverage or another Medicare plan, this usually doesn’t apply.
New York Medigap rule | What it means |
|---|---|
Community rating | Same premium for everyone in your area, whatever your age or health |
Year-round guaranteed issue | Apply any month; no health questions; can’t be turned down |
Pre-existing condition wait | 2 to 6 months at some companies, only if you lacked recent coverage |
Rates set by region | Long Island has its own rate region; compare official rates on the NY Department of Financial Services rate lookup |
The trade-off: because New York lets anyone in at any age, supplement premiums here start higher than in many states. But they don’t jump just because you get older.
Which supplement plan fits you?
Every Medigap plan with the same letter has the exact same benefits, no matter which company sells it. A Plan G from one company covers the same things as a Plan G from another. What differs is the price, how steady that price stays and the service you get. These are the plans most Long Islanders choose between:
Plan | What you pay when you get care | Monthly premium | Often a good fit for |
|---|---|---|---|
Plan G | Only the yearly Part B deductible ($283 in 2026; 2027 amount announced by CMS each fall) | Higher | People who want predictable costs and see doctors often |
Plan N | The Part B deductible, up to $20 per office visit and up to $50 per ER visit that doesn’t lead to a hospital stay | Lower than G | People comfortable with small copays to save on premiums |
High-Deductible Plan G | A yearly deductible of roughly $3,000 (set by CMS each year), then the same coverage as Plan G | Lowest | Healthy people who want a low premium plus protection from big bills |
Plan F | Nothing, including the Part B deductible | Highest | Only people eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020 |
A few things to remember:
- No supplement covers prescriptions. You’ll add a separate Part D plan (see below).
- Plan N’s “excess charges” gap matters less here. New York limits how much doctors can bill above Medicare’s approved amount, which makes Plan N a stronger value on Long Island than in many states.
- Same letter, different price. Long Island has its own rate region. Compare companies on the official NY Department of Financial Services rate lookup before you pick one.
The bottom line on supplements: if you try Medicare Advantage and later decide you want the freedom of a supplement, New York gives you a way back. That’s a big deal, and many national websites don’t mention it.
Medicare Advantage in 2027: Nassau vs. Suffolk
Nassau has more Medicare Advantage choices than Suffolk in 2027, but more choices doesn’t mean better choices. Here’s how the two counties stack up.
2027 plans | Nassau County | Suffolk County |
|---|---|---|
Standard Medicare Advantage plans | 28 | 18 |
Plans with a $0 monthly premium | 15 | 7 |
Plans without drug coverage | 3 | 3 |
Special Needs Plans for people with Medicare and Medicaid (D-SNP) | 25 | 15 |
Special Needs Plans for certain chronic conditions (C-SNP) | 4 | 1 |
Special Needs Plans for people in a nursing home or needing that level of care (I-SNP) | 6 | 5 |
A closer look by plan type
HMOs are the most common plan type in both counties, but most Long Islanders in Medicare Advantage are enrolled in PPOs. Each county has 3 plans with no drug coverage, which matters if you take prescriptions.
Plan type | Nassau plans | Nassau $0 premium | Nassau without drugs | Suffolk plans | Suffolk $0 premium | Suffolk without drugs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
HMO | 13 | 3 | 0 | 9 | 1 | 0 |
PPO | 10 | 8 | 1 | 4 | 2 | 1 |
HMO-POS | 5 | 4 | 2 | 5 | 4 | 2 |
Total | 28 | 15 | 3 | 18 | 7 | 3 |
Source: CMS 2027 plan landscape data for Nassau and Suffolk counties.
Why plans without drug coverage exist: they’re built for veterans who get prescriptions through the VA, or people with drug coverage from a union or former employer. If that’s not you, skip them. Joining one without other creditable drug coverage can trigger a lifelong Part D late penalty.
The number most ads won’t mention
Every Medicare Advantage plan has a yearly out-of-pocket maximum, the most you’d pay for covered medical care in a bad year. The federal limit for 2027 is $9,850, and most Long Island plans set theirs right at that limit.
2027 out-of-pocket maximum | Nassau plans | Suffolk plans |
|---|---|---|
At the $9,850 federal limit | 23 of 28 | 16 of 18 |
Below the limit | 5 of 28 | 2 of 18 |
Lowest available | $6,800 (a plan built for veterans, no drug coverage) | $6,800 (same plan) |
In plain English: a $0 premium plan on Long Island can still cost close to $10,000 in a year with a hospital stay or cancer treatment. That isn’t a reason to avoid Medicare Advantage. It’s a reason to know your worst case before you sign up.
Companies offering Medicare Advantage on Long Island in 2027: Aetna, Anthem, EmblemHealth, Healthfirst, Humana, VNS Health and Wellcare offer plans in both counties. Devoted Health and VillageCareMAX are in Nassau only. UnitedHealthcare offers Special Needs Plans here, but no standard Medicare Advantage plans. HealthSpring (formerly Cigna) is leaving New York for 2027, and Humana’s Long Island PPOs are ending, so many neighbors need a new plan this year.
A few things I tell every client when they look at a list like this:
- Look past the premium. Check the yearly out-of-pocket maximum, your hospital copays and your drug costs. That’s where the real money is.
- Check your doctors, every year. Networks change. A plan that worked last year may have dropped your specialist.
- Star ratings help, but they’re not everything. A 4-star plan that doesn’t include your cardiologist isn’t a good plan for you.
- East End and North Fork folks, take note. If you live out past Riverhead, make sure the plan’s network actually reaches you. Some networks are thin out east.
Start with your doctors and hospitals
On Long Island, the hospital system you trust should drive your Medicare decision, not the other way around. Most of our care runs through a handful of big systems:
- Northwell Health
- Stony Brook Medicine
- NYU Langone
- Catholic Health
- Mount Sinai
- Optum (many local doctor groups)
With Original Medicare and a supplement, you can use any of them, plus Memorial Sloan Kettering or a specialist in Manhattan, as long as they take Medicare. With Medicare Advantage, you need to check that your doctors, your hospital and any specialists are in the plan’s network.
My advice: before you look at a single plan, write down every doctor you see and the hospital you’d want to go to in an emergency. That one list will rule out half the plans on the table.
Drug plans (Part D): only 9 choices in 2027
If you have a supplement, you’ll need a separate drug plan, and your choices are limited. There are only 9 standalone Part D plans in New York for 2027, and they’re the same in Nassau and Suffolk.
- Monthly premiums run from $37.30 to $238.30.
- 6 of the 9 plans have the maximum $700 deductible.
- None of them has a $0 deductible.
The cheapest premium is rarely the cheapest plan. What matters is the total you’ll pay for your specific medications over the year, at your pharmacy. Most of my clients fill at CVS, Walgreens, Walmart or Costco, and prices can differ quite a bit between them, even on the same plan.
The good news: no matter which drug plan you choose, your yearly cost for covered prescriptions is capped at $2,400 in 2027.
A New York bonus most people miss: EPIC
EPIC is New York State’s drug program for seniors. It works alongside your Part D plan and picks up much of what Part D doesn’t. More than 325,000 New Yorkers use it, and the income limits are higher than most people think.
EPIC plan | Single income | Married income | How it works |
|---|---|---|---|
Fee Plan | Up to $20,000 | Up to $26,000 | Pay a small yearly fee, then $3 to $20 copays |
Deductible Plan | $20,001 to $75,000 | $26,001 to $100,000 | Meet a yearly EPIC deductible, then $3 to $20 copays |
Premium help | Up to $23,000 | Up to $29,000 | EPIC also helps pay your Part D premium |
You must be 65 or older, live in New York and have (or be eligible for) a Part D plan. You can apply any time of year. Source: NYS Department of Health, EPIC program.
Dates to circle on the calendar
When | What you can do |
|---|---|
October 15 – December 7 | Annual Enrollment: switch Medicare Advantage plans, change drug plans, or move between Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare. Changes start January 1. |
January 1 – March 31 | If you’re in a Medicare Advantage plan, you get one more chance to switch plans or go back to Original Medicare. |
Your 65th birthday | A seven-month window around your birthday month to sign up for Medicare for the first time. |
Any time (New York) | Apply for a Medicare Supplement plan. |
Don’t wait until the first week of December. That’s when everyone calls, and the good appointments fill up fast.
Paul’s Honest Take
After 18 years and more than 5,000 clients, here’s what I’ve learned: there’s no “best” Medicare plan on Long Island. There’s only the best plan for you. If you’re healthy, love your local doctors and want to keep monthly costs low, a Medicare Advantage plan can work well. If you travel, see specialists in Manhattan or just want to stop worrying about bills, a supplement is often worth the higher premium. New York’s year-round supplement rules give you room to change your mind. The worst choice is the one made in a rush because a TV ad told you to call.
Your 5-step checklist before you choose
- List every doctor, specialist and hospital you use.
- List every medication, with the dose, and your favorite pharmacy.
- Decide what matters more: a low monthly premium, or low costs when you get care.
- Compare your top plans by total yearly cost, not just the premium.
- Check that your doctors are in network for 2027, not just 2026.
Let’s talk it through, no pressure
I answer my own phone. No call centers, no hand-offs. As an independent broker, I work with many companies, so my job is to show you your options, not push one plan. For 2027, I work with 9 of the 10 Medicare Advantage companies on Long Island, and I can offer 24 of Nassau’s 28 standard Medicare Advantage plans and 16 of Suffolk’s 18. If a plan I don’t offer turns out to be your best fit, I’ll tell you, and point you to Medicare.gov to enroll. My help costs you nothing.
- Call or text: 631-358-5793
- Email: medicare@paulbinsurance.com
- Book a time: Schedule a free review
- Learn at your own pace: Join one of my free Medicare seminars or webinars
- See the full guide: Visit my Long Island Medicare guide for hospitals, plan lists and towns we serve
Frequently asked questions
How many Medicare Advantage plans are on Long Island in 2027?
Nassau County has 28 standard Medicare Advantage plans and Suffolk County has 18. Both counties also have Special Needs Plans for people with Medicaid, certain chronic conditions or nursing-home-level needs.
Are Medicare plans different in Nassau and Suffolk?
Yes. Plans are approved county by county. Nassau has more plans and two extra companies (Devoted Health and VillageCareMAX). Always compare plans using your own ZIP code.
Can I switch to a Medicare Supplement in New York any time?
Yes. New York requires supplement companies to accept you year-round with no health questions. Some may apply a short waiting period for pre-existing conditions if you didn’t have recent coverage.
Does my age change my Medigap price in New York?
No. New York uses community rating, so a 67-year-old and an 85-year-old in the same area pay the same rate for the same plan.
Is a $0 premium Medicare Advantage plan really free?
No. You still pay your Part B premium, plus copays when you use care, up to the plan’s yearly limit (no more than $9,850 in-network in 2027).
Will I lose access to Northwell or Stony Brook with Medicare Advantage?
It depends on the plan. Networks vary, and they can change each year. Check every doctor and hospital before you enroll.
I have a HealthSpring PPO plan. Can I keep it in 2027?
No. HealthSpring (the former Cigna Medicare plans) is leaving New York entirely for 2027, so every HealthSpring Medicare Advantage plan on Long Island ends on December 31, 2026. You should have received a non-renewal letter in early October. Here’s what that means:
- Your coverage continues through December 31, 2026. Keep using your plan until then.
- You have extra time to choose. Besides Open Enrollment (October 15 to December 7), you get a Special Enrollment Period that runs through the end of February 2027. Choose by December 31 to avoid a gap.
- If you do nothing, you’ll be moved to Original Medicare on January 1 with no drug coverage and no supplement.
- You can switch to a supplement. New York’s year-round Medigap rules mean you can move to Original Medicare plus a supplement and a Part D plan, with no health questions.
Did Humana get rid of its PPO plans on Long Island?
For 2027, yes. Humana’s PPO plans that served Nassau and Suffolk, including its HumanaChoice and Direct Choice Giveback PPOs, aren’t returning for 2027. Humana’s only standard Medicare Advantage plan on Long Island in 2027 is an HMO (Humana Gold Plus), which generally requires you to stay in network. If you were in a Humana PPO, you should have received a non-renewal letter and have the same options and Special Enrollment Period as HealthSpring members. If seeing doctors out of network matters to you, compare the remaining PPOs from other companies, or consider a supplement.
What Medicare Advantage plans are accepted at Stony Brook Hospital?
It depends on the specific plan, not just the insurance company. Stony Brook Medicine itself warns patients not to assume they’re in network just because their insurance company’s name appears on its list. One company can have some plans that include Stony Brook and others that don’t.
The short answer: Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, EmblemHealth and Healthfirst all have Medicare Advantage plans that work with Stony Brook. Even so, confirm your exact plan before you enroll:
- Check Stony Brook’s health plan participation guide for your exact plan name.
- Search for Stony Brook in the plan’s 2027 provider directory.
- Call the plan’s member services and ask about Stony Brook University Hospital and the specific Stony Brook doctors you see.
Stony Brook Southampton and Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital (Greenport) can have different network status, so check each one you use. With Original Medicare and a supplement, all Stony Brook hospitals accept you because they accept Medicare.
What’s the most I’ll pay for prescriptions in 2027?
The Part D yearly cap is $2,400 for covered drugs. If your income qualifies, New York’s EPIC program can lower your costs further.
Does it cost more to use a local agent?
No. Plan prices are the same whether you enroll on your own, through a call center or with a local broker.
Trusted resources for Long Islanders
You don’t have to take my word for any of this. These are official, non-sales resources I send my own clients to.
Resource | What it helps with | How to reach it |
|---|---|---|
Compare every 2027 plan in your ZIP code | 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) | |
Official Medicare Supplement prices for Long Island | Online rate lookup | |
State help with prescription costs | 1-800-332-3742 | |
HIICAP (Suffolk County Office for the Aging) | Free, unbiased Medicare counseling, including at local libraries | 631-979-9490 ext. 18 |
Nonprofit help line for Medicare questions and appeals | 1-800-333-4114 |
Sources
- CMS 2027 Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket limits (summary)
- AP: 2027 Part D cap and deductible changes
- NY DFS: Medicare Supplement plans, carriers and pre-existing condition waits
- Medicare Rights Center: New York Medigap rules
- NYS Department of Health: EPIC income limits
- 2027 Nassau and Suffolk plan counts and carriers: The Modern Medicare Agency county stat sheets, from CMS 2027 plan filings
About the author
Paul Barrett, CMIP, is the founder and principal agent of The Modern Medicare Agency in Melville, NY. He’s an independent, Medicare-only broker with 18+ years of experience, AHIP-certified, licensed in 37 states and appointed with 40+ insurance companies. He has helped more than 5,000 clients, hosts the Wise Guys Retirement Talk podcast, wrote Medicare Mastery Unlocked, and has lived on Long Island for 55 years.
NPN 5316441 · 445 Broad Hollow Rd, Melville, NY 11747 · 631-358-5793 · medicare@paulbinsurance.com
Last reviewed: October 2026. Plan figures are for the 2027 plan year and can change. Always confirm details for your ZIP code.
Important disclosures
We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 9 organizations which offer 24 products in Nassau County and 16 products in Suffolk County. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.
Paul Barrett and The Modern Medicare Agency are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. This article is for educational purposes and is not a recommendation of any specific plan. Plan availability, benefits, premiums and networks vary by county and ZIP code and may change each year. Enrollment in some plans is limited to certain times of the year unless you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period. Special Needs Plans are available only to people who meet eligibility requirements. Paul Barrett is a licensed insurance agent, NPN 5316441.




