If you’re on Long Island and you’ve heard whispers about Medicare Advantage plans pulling back for 2027, you heard right. National carrier exits are landing directly on Nassau and Suffolk counties this year — here’s the full picture, including what to expect in your mailbox and the rights it unlocks if your plan is one of them.
Key Takeaways
- Medicare Advantage plans are confirmed to be leaving both Nassau and Suffolk counties for 2027, as part of a broader national pullback from carriers like Humana and UnitedHealthcare, projected to affect over 1.1 million members nationwide.
- Even surviving plans aren’t untouched. Nearly 70% of health plan executives admit they’re cutting benefits — expect smaller dental/vision/hearing caps, reduced OTC allowances, shrinking networks, and stricter prior authorization, not just outright exits.
- A quiet compliance change removes the mid-year reminder plans used to send about unused benefits — starting in 2027, tracking your own gym, dental, and OTC allowances is entirely on you.
- Not all the news is contraction: Devoted Health, a fast-growing national carrier, has confirmed New York as one of five new expansion states for 2027 — though which specific counties remains unconfirmed as of this writing.
- A plan termination unlocks a real federal right: guaranteed-issue access to a Medigap policy with no medical underwriting — but only if you don’t enroll in a new Medicare Advantage plan first.
- Your coverage doesn’t end the moment a notice arrives. Current benefits stay active through December 31, and you have until roughly late February to finalize a new plan if needed — though waiting past December 31 delays your new coverage’s start date.
- The two counties have genuinely different plan landscapes — Nassau’s standard enrollment is led by Aetna, while Suffolk’s is led by Anthem, with UnitedHealthcare trailing well behind both in actual local enrollment despite being a national giant.
Yes, Plans Are Leaving Nassau and Suffolk
This isn’t a rumor circulating at the diner — it’s a confirmed, documented trend. National carriers have announced targeted pullbacks and plan terminations specifically affecting Long Island for the 2027 plan year, as part of the same broader pullback we’ve been tracking nationally, where Humana and UnitedHealthcare alone are projected to shed over 1.1 million members combined. Regional broker alerts have confirmed Nassau and Suffolk are directly in that path. (For the full national picture — including why this is happening even after CMS increased payment rates for 2027 — see our complete breakdown of the 2027 Medicare Advantage shakeup.)
Your Long Island Timeline

| Date | What Happens |
|---|---|
| By September 30 | Continuing plans mail their Annual Notice of Change (ANOC), detailing changes to copays, premiums, and benefits. |
| By October 2 | If your specific plan is being eliminated in Nassau or Suffolk, you’ll receive a formal Non-Renewal Notice. |
| October 15 – December 7 | The Annual Election Period — your primary window to pick a replacement plan. |
| December 8 – late February | A Special Enrollment Period if your plan was terminated, though enrolling before December 31 avoids a coverage gap. |
What Happens If Your Plan Leaves
Your coverage doesn’t disappear overnight. If you get a non-renewal notice, your current plan — benefits, copays, network — stays fully active through December 31.
You unlock a genuinely valuable right. A formal plan termination triggers a rare federal Guaranteed-Issue window: you can return to Original Medicare and buy a Medigap policy (like Plan G) without medical underwriting. Insurers can’t deny you or charge more based on pre-existing conditions during this window. (New York residents get an even stronger version of this protection year-round — see our full Medicare Advantage vs. Medigap breakdown for the New York-specific details.)
The one mistake that forfeits that right: enrolling in a new Medicare Advantage plan before deciding whether you want to use your Guaranteed-Issue window for Medigap instead. Once you enroll in a new MA plan, that window closes. Decide your path deliberately before enrolling in anything. (Full detail on this exact trap: Your Medicare Advantage Plan Is Being Discontinued? Here’s What to Do Next.)
Even surviving plans aren’t untouched. Nearly 70% of health plan executives nationally admit they’re cutting benefits to protect margins rather than raising premiums outright — and Long Island’s surviving plans are no exception. Specifically, watch for:
- Smaller dental, vision, and hearing caps
- Reduced quarterly Over-the-Counter (OTC) allowances
- Shrinking provider networks, as carriers tighten which doctors and hospital systems they’ll pay
- Stricter prior authorization requirements, even for routine procedures
Don’t assume “no notice” means “no changes” — read your ANOC letter closely regardless.
A Quiet Change Worth Knowing About: No More Mid-Year Reminders
Here’s a compliance shift that’s easy to miss entirely: Medicare has dropped the requirement that plans send a mid-year reminder about unused supplemental benefits — the letter that used to nudge you about leftover gym credits, dental allowances, or OTC dollars sitting unused. Starting in 2027, that reminder is gone. Tracking and using your own benefits before they reset is now entirely on you. If you’ve relied on that mid-year nudge in the past, it’s worth setting your own calendar reminder this year instead.
What Coverage Actually Costs on Long Island
Local numbers help make this concrete. For the current plan year, Long Island Medicare Advantage premiums have generally run in the $18 to $40 a month range, with plenty of $0-premium options still available — though the statewide maximum in New York can reach as high as $199.20 for richer plans. Out-of-pocket maximums locally span roughly $3,000 to $9,250, averaging around $6,300 statewide. (We’ve covered why Aetna specifically has built such a strong local following on Long Island — see What Makes Aetna Medicare Advantage So Popular in Long Island.)
Local Long Island News Worth Knowing
A few developments specific to this market, beyond the national carrier pullback story:
- Costco is entering the senior insurance space, partnering with SCAN Group to offer Medicare Advantage-related products at select locations — a genuinely new entrant worth watching in the local market.
- Governor Hochul has publicly warned that broader federal changes could add future cost pressure to prescription drug coverage for New York’s roughly 13 million Medicare-eligible residents.
- A new bifurcated appeals process now splits how grievances are handled for dual-eligible members requesting services or filing appeals, effective for claims after January 1, 2026 — relevant given how large Nassau’s D-SNP population is.
A Rare Bit of Good News: A New Carrier May Be Coming to New York
Not every headline this year is about carriers pulling back. Devoted Health — a fast-growing, tech-driven Medicare Advantage carrier — has confirmed a major national expansion for 2027: five new states and 342 new counties, bringing its footprint to 34 states and roughly 55% of the entire individual Medicare Advantage population. New York is officially one of those five new states.
What isn’t confirmed yet is which New York counties will actually be included — Devoted’s own materials are appropriately cautious on that specific point, and no verified source has named Nassau or Suffolk directly as of this writing. (Worth a specific note: Devoted already operates in a different Nassau County — in Florida, near Jacksonville — which appears to be the source of some secondhand claims mistakenly suggesting they’re already confirmed here on Long Island.) We’re watching this closely and will update as county-level details become public. (For the full story on Devoted Health and what its arrival could mean for New York, see our deeper dive here.)
A Quick Look at Each County’s Plan Landscape
The two counties don’t look identical when you dig into actual enrollment data. Nassau’s standard individual plan market (roughly 51,753 enrollees) is currently led by Aetna Medicare Elite, followed by AARP/UHC and Healthfirst. Suffolk’s standard market (roughly 56,629 enrollees) tells a different story, with Anthem holding the top local spot. Nassau also has a substantial Dual-Eligible Special Needs Plan (D-SNP) population — about 30,649 additional beneficiaries — where Healthfirst’s regional footprint dominates even more decisively than in the standard market.
We’re publishing a full, detailed breakdown of each county separately, since the specific plans and numbers genuinely differ enough to deserve their own deep dive rather than a combined summary:
- Medicare Advantage in Nassau County: The Full 2027 Breakdown (coming soon)
- Medicare Advantage in Suffolk County: The Full 2027 Breakdown (coming soon)
Frequently Asked Questions
I live on Long Island — does this definitely affect my plan? Not necessarily. Plan exits are targeted at specific plans and carriers, not every plan in the county. The safest move is to read your ANOC or non-renewal letter closely rather than assume either way.
If my plan isn’t leaving, do I need to do anything? It’s still worth reviewing your ANOC letter. Widespread benefit reductions are happening across surviving plans too — reduced OTC allowances, dental caps, and higher specialist copays are common even without a full plan exit.
Why are national giants like UnitedHealthcare losing ground on Long Island specifically? Locally, Aetna and regional insurers like Healthfirst have built a stronger foothold in actual enrollment than their national market share might suggest — Long Island’s on-the-ground plan landscape doesn’t always mirror the national picture.
What should I do first if I get a non-renewal notice? Save the letter and its envelope — you’ll need it as proof for Medigap’s guaranteed-issue right. Then decide your path (new Medicare Advantage plan, or Original Medicare plus Medigap) before enrolling in anything.
I heard my plan won’t remind me about unused benefits anymore — is that true? Yes, starting in 2027, plans are no longer required to send the mid-year reminder about unused supplemental benefits like gym credits, dental allowances, or OTC dollars. It’s worth setting your own reminder partway through the year to make sure you’re not leaving money on the table.
Is it true a new carrier, Devoted Health, is coming to Nassau County? Not confirmed. Devoted Health has confirmed New York as one of five new states it’s expanding into for 2027, but which specific New York counties are included hasn’t been officially released. Some secondhand claims naming Nassau specifically appear to stem from confusion with a different Nassau County that Devoted already serves in Florida. We’ll update this once real New York county-level details are public.
The Bottom Line
Long Island isn’t watching this Medicare Advantage shakeup from a distance — Nassau and Suffolk are directly in it, for the same reasons carriers are pulling back nationally. The good news: nothing about this has to catch you off guard if you read your mail closely this September and October, and understand your rights before you enroll in anything new.
If you want to talk through your specific plan, your specific doctors, or what a non-renewal notice means for you, that’s exactly the conversation worth having before December 7.
Call 631-358-5793 or visit paulbinsurance.com to talk through your specific situation.
Paul Barrett, CMIP, is the founder of The Modern Medicare Agency, based in Melville, NY — right here on Long Island — and has spent 18+ years exclusively helping people navigate Medicare. He’s licensed in 37 states, represents more than 40 carriers, and has personally helped over 5,000 clients choose coverage that actually fits their lives.
Related Reading
- The Medicare Advantage Shakeup Heading Into 2027: What’s Really Happening, By the Numbers
- Your Medicare Advantage Plan Is Being Discontinued? Here’s What Happens Next
- Medicare Advantage vs. Medigap: The Honest Breakdown
Sources
- Healthcare Dive — UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage 2027 Market Competitive
- 247wallst.com — Humana Is Cutting Medicare Advantage Plans for 2027
- 247wallst.com — Starting in 2027, Your Advantage Plan No Longer Has to Remind You
- Kiplinger — Changes Coming to Medicare in 2027
- News 12 Long Island — Costco to Launch Senior-Focused Insurance Plans
- News 12 Long Island — Gov. Hochul Warns Medicare Changes Could Increase Prescription Drug Costs
- Devoted Health — Our Service Area
- NY Health Access — Appeals Process Changes for Dual-Eligible Members
- Medicare.org — Nassau County Plan Enrollment Data
- Medicare.org — Suffolk County Plan Enrollment Data
- Medicare.org — Nassau County SNP Enrollment Data





